Are you ready for 7 million people on tiny Singapore?
-
pirate:
Oic.... My apology if understood u, yes some do have that perception....Dreamgear:
IT is not part of the economy? You seems to harbour some disdain for this particular segment.....
I am just amused that some of our IT boys seem to think that the IT department of an MNC is the same as the 'IT industry'. If you are in the IT department of a company, you are not in the IT industry. You are performing a supporting function to whatever industry your company is in.
The IT i am referring to is the huawei, hcl and hp services of the world.... -
Dora1:
Sorry no offense. MNC come here because of tax incentives. There is no free lunch.
I am not in the IT industry. Nothing even close. And we face the same problem.
And I, as a Singaporean, am very offended with what 3boys said abt the SC workforce. Are we seriously so bad? I am proud to be a Singaporean and of my fellow Singaporean colleagues and our work ethics. Can you please enlighten me if the SG workforce is so bad, why do MNCs come? For the infrastructure?
Want good workforce go China. They can make and fake iPhones. :scared:
-
pirate:
I think you have to understand that back in the 1990s and early 2000s there was this boom in the IT demand in Singapore and government instructed the tertiary to produce more graduates in this field. I was a Multimedia student in SP during early 2000 and the demand was so hot that companies were snapping up the students even before graduation.
And... surprise, surprise, we are back in the IT departments (We have an IT industry to speak of?!). Is it any surprise that the grumblings from this particular segment is the loudest online? Apparently we are supposed to craft national economic and labour policies based on the rumblings of those in the IT line. :siao:Dreamgear:
Fairy tale? Just because you never experienced it does not mean the above situation does not exists. This is very real in the IT industry.
Of course, The singaporean work culture and ethics is still very much in demand... In indonesia and vietnam.....
Now, I am interested to know which IT MNCs in Singapore have this problem with their HR departments. Apple? Microsoft? Yahoo? Google? eBay? Lucasfilm? Trek? Creative?
Fast forward to today and obviously the demand has slowed down by quite a lot. The problem is now there is a large pool of tertiary IT graduates produced during those times vying for that ever diminishing pie. By the way, IT departments ever since my time has always been rather FT heavy and it is still true till today. I still got in touch with my poly mates and seriously a large number of them are no longer in IT line. And yes, that includes me.
So now there are a lot of disgruntled IT graduates making a lot of noise online because they find it hard to compete in the job market. The reality of the job market now is very different from last time. I sincerely hope you are not suggesting that when the when drafting national policies government should ignore these group of people. After all they are still your fellow citizens trying to make a honest living in this city. -
Dreamgear:
The IT i am referring to is the huawei, hcl and hp services of the world....
I hope our IT boys know that Huawei is a PRC company and HCL is an Indian company.
As for HP. Hee hee hee, we all know what kind of shape HP is in nowadays... :evil: -
sinoboy:
Please lor, our cost are 3 to 4 times higher, the tax incentives are no use. It only makes a difference if the cost are comparable e.g with Europe or US
Sorry no offense. MNC come here because of tax incentives. There is no free lunch.Dora1:
I am not in the IT industry. Nothing even close. And we face the same problem.
And I, as a Singaporean, am very offended with what 3boys said abt the SC workforce. Are we seriously so bad? I am proud to be a Singaporean and of my fellow Singaporean colleagues and our work ethics. Can you please enlighten me if the SG workforce is so bad, why do MNCs come? For the infrastructure?
Want good workforce go China. They can make and fake iPhones. :scared: -
Dreamaurora:
No. I am suggesting that they should be re-training. IT is very competitive, cut-throat and borderless unless they are one of those rare animals that can also make creative content. The writing is on the wall when the Malaysia IT industry can make better cartoons than Singapore. It is a perfect example of how a skill-based competitive advantage that we supposedly enjoy can disappear practically overnight.I think you have to understand that back in the 1990s and early 2000s there was this boom in the IT demand in Singapore and government instructed the tertiary to produce more graduates in this field. I was a Multimedia student in SP during early 2000 and the demand was so hot that companies were snapping up the students even before graduation.
Fast forward to today and obviously the demand has slowed down by quite a lot. The problem is now there is a large pool of tertiary IT graduates produced during those times vying for that ever diminishing pie. By the way, IT departments ever since my time has always been rather FT heavy and it is still true till today. I still got in touch with my poly mates and seriously a large number of them are no longer in IT line. And yes, that includes me.
So now there are a lot of disgruntled IT graduates making a lot of noise online because they find it hard to compete in the job market. The reality of the job market now is very different from last time. I sincerely hope you are not suggesting that when the when drafting national policies government should ignore these group of people. After all they are still your fellow citizens trying to make a honest living in this city. -
pirate:
Is just semantics..Dreamgear:
IT is not part of the economy? You seems to harbour some disdain for this particular segment.....
I am just amused that some of our IT boys seem to think that the IT department of an MNC is the same as the 'IT industry'. If you are in the IT department of a company, you are not in the IT industry. You are performing a supporting function to whatever industry your company is in.
You mean if that mnc decides to outsource its IT support to an IT company, then the part of it suddenly becomes part of IT industry economy but when it was done in-house, it was not considered an IT economy...is meaningless classification. -
3Boys:
A leopard doesn't change its spots. Seeing is believing.WeiHan:
You should go to the ground and really learn what happens. I am sure theory in their plan don't take into considerations such as human nature to employ their own kind, how about office politics and culture? If it becomes predominantly foreign, then locals (even good in skills or knowledge) may not fit into the culture anymore...and there are many more possible factors that may not be considered in the beautiful master plan theory that gov has in mind...then reality drift further and further away from theory.....
What a fairy tale. :roll:
Sad thing is that some people actually believe it.
Singaporeans have gone overseas and excelled in foreign companies in foreign lands. For the longest time, MNCs that have set up here have always had mostly staffed with HQ people to begin with.
The much vaunted world beating Singapore worker being run over in a company because of a foreign culture? :siao:
When I wrote the above, I have some acquaintances who are in the IT line facing such problems. One of them has a first class honours degree from NUS and was already facing such issues with his hard-found first job after graduation. The experience of a few forumners further strengtened my belief that the scenario is true. -
pirate:
Initiatives of what? Cut pay and do factory workers job with a engineering degree or whatever degrees?
Did the 10 uni grads who are content doing data entry and low level admin work make the effort to take that initiative? Stop making excuses for them.
Some people do that (asking for lower position job with hefty pay cut) but the interviewers just look at them with disbelief. -
pirate:
I am not familiar with IT lines. But from my impression, if you do not have a job, what retraining helps? One that I knew isn't average. 1st class honors degree from NUS isn't an easy feat especially we have bright foreign students competing in there nowadays. I know you may say a degree, whatever it is means nothing nowaday...but my point is that some of them facing problems aren't just average IQ guys...and they have no EQ problem also....no communication skill problem...normal high intelligence people but facing this kind of problem.
No. I am suggesting that they should be re-training. IT is very competitive, cut-throat and borderless unless they are one of those rare animals that can also make creative content. The writing is on the wall when the Malaysia IT industry can make better cartoons than Singapore. It is a perfect example of how a skill-based competitive advantage that we supposedly enjoy can disappear practically overnight.Dreamaurora:
I think you have to understand that back in the 1990s and early 2000s there was this boom in the IT demand in Singapore and government instructed the tertiary to produce more graduates in this field. I was a Multimedia student in SP during early 2000 and the demand was so hot that companies were snapping up the students even before graduation.
Fast forward to today and obviously the demand has slowed down by quite a lot. The problem is now there is a large pool of tertiary IT graduates produced during those times vying for that ever diminishing pie. By the way, IT departments ever since my time has always been rather FT heavy and it is still true till today. I still got in touch with my poly mates and seriously a large number of them are no longer in IT line. And yes, that includes me.
So now there are a lot of disgruntled IT graduates making a lot of noise online because they find it hard to compete in the job market. The reality of the job market now is very different from last time. I sincerely hope you are not suggesting that when the when drafting national policies government should ignore these group of people. After all they are still your fellow citizens trying to make a honest living in this city.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better š
Register Login14
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects