DSA 2012
-
Malsy9:
You can read about the program in their school website. Recently, it was reportrd in the papers that they won some art-science competition. I think you can also read it in the website.Hi does anyone have any information on SJI Ip
Program . DS not sure if he should take up program considering they are just starting IP this year . Anyone have any information would appreciate a lot . My son dream school is ACSI but reasons same as above not sure if he should go there . -
BeContented:
Understand your concern but really, if u and your son like the program and the school environment feels good, go ahead with it.Most of all, being amongst the rich would mean DS has to be very strong in his character, must be able to withstand the temptation, possible taunting (intentional/unintentional) from his peers etc. He will need to learn and I will need to manage his 'why others have, I can't :stompfeet:
To begin with, every sch (esp independent schools), have rich kids. It doesnt mean that rich kids would flaunt their wealth in schools.
It is a misconception that ACSI is flooded with such boys. The truth is that 10% of the boys are on Financial Assistance Scheme. My son goes to ACSI and he is in sec 3 IP now. He was from a neighbourhood primary school and we stay in HDB flat. Never once, did i hear him complain about his friend (may it be politician's or president's grandson, CEO's son...blabla) appearing proud or felt pressured to own a certain expensive gadget becos his friends have it.
His schoolmates are also very happy coming to my HDB home for stayovers and work on projects, etc. None of them appeared snobbish.
As for donations, it is on a volunteer basis. Once after chinese new year (the money collected will use to fund needy schoolmates for yearly overseas trip starting in secondary 2), the other sometime midyr.
Happy deciding! :)))) -
Blue Dolphin:
If I'm not mistaken, IP schools can now offer DSA up to 50% of their intake.jtoh:
[quote=\"phankao\"]
I guess schools like SNGS, CHS & SCGS are still bound by the rule of 10% of their maximum vacancy level then. Which in this case is 30. So this \"rule\" has not been allowed to be relaxed by MOE even with introduction of IP. These 3 schools have to abide by this ruling bc they are not independent schools, unlike RI, etc. Oh well. No wonder CHS for eg. Only opened DSA for sports & IP and closed up all the previous DSA domains (via other CCA). Bc they cannot offer that many places. All along 30 places for DSA, now STILL 30 places.
phttph ----> for IP DSA, they don't look to see whether from affiliated. Whoever is worthy is the key. They don't *reserve* for affiliated at all during DSA.
If it is indeed correct that SNGS DSA 30 or so places, then would it not have been a waste of resources for the school and parents?
It would be reasonable to assume that most if not all of the 30 successful students would have also DSA other schools in similar tier (e.g. NJC, SCGS, Ceda, MGS, etc) or better ones (e.g. RGS and NYGH). Some of the successful ones may choose SNGS and some may not; surely those who have CO or WL from RGS and NYGS would reasonably not. Some would have also CO from other similar tier schools and decide to not choose SNGS, let's say 50-50. Thus, that would leave a small percentage of the 30 successful students eventually taking up the offer. So the school has expended much effort to recruit 8 or 10 or 12 students through DSA (12 out of a cohort of 180 IP, ~7%).
As a parent, if it was made known that there would only be 30 places, instead of the \"up to 50%, i.e. 90 or so\" places, then surely it would have made a significant impact on the decision to DSA SNGS; precious time, effort and hope could have been better spent.
Perhaps it was a test-run for SNGS management? :?[/quote]
I couldn't agree more with you !! -
psle_stressed_mum:
I m really happy to hear that NJC is relax, i wouldnt be having 2nd thoughts as to whether my dd should take on their CO... ive heard its rather stressful there frm quite a no of ppl. think there will be an open house, can go n check it out in october and talk to their studentsI have been reading all the threads and hope to get some advice from all the parents here.
DS has a confirmed offer from both HCI and NJC and am in dilemma about which one to choose. His Chinese is very weak and I am worried that he will not survive in HCI. On the other hand, I heard that NJC is too relaxed and I dont know whether that is good for the A levels which is ultimately the more important thing.
Any information on both schools would be appreciated
-
breezy:
Understand your concern but really, if u and your son like the program and the school environment feels good, go ahead with it.BeContented:
Most of all, being amongst the rich would mean DS has to be very strong in his character, must be able to withstand the temptation, possible taunting (intentional/unintentional) from his peers etc. He will need to learn and I will need to manage his 'why others have, I can't :stompfeet:
To begin with, every sch (esp independent schools), have rich kids. It doesnt mean that rich kids would flaunt their wealth in schools.
It is a misconception that ACSI is flooded with such boys. The truth is that 10% of the boys are on Financial Assistance Scheme. My son goes to ACSI and he is in sec 3 IP now. He was from a neighbourhood primary school and we stay in HDB flat. Never once, did i hear him complain about his friend (may it be politician's or president's grandson, CEO's son...blabla) appearing proud or felt pressured to own a certain expensive gadget becos his friends have it.
His schoolmates are also very happy coming to my HDB home for stayovers and work on projects, etc. None of them appeared snobbish.
As for donations, it is on a volunteer basis. Once after chinese new year (the money collected will use to fund needy schoolmates for yearly overseas trip starting in secondary 2), the other sometime midyr.
Happy deciding! :))))
I also know not all are rich, but perhaps the ratio might be on the higher side hence this perception (plus people like us think think think then dare not go ACSI ....end up only rich ones went ahead to join :rotflmao: ) Anyway, it's all speculation
As for flaunting their wealth, guess I did mention that some are unintentional and sometimes, it's ourselves who gets sensitive/envious/jealous/upset cos cannot afford .... :oops: But I just wanted to highlight this aspect cos' it can get sticky if the child gets 'affected'. My DS is ok, but DD is one such gal who would whine over such things....took a lot of effort to explain and discipline
:frustrated: So must really depend on the child.
Anyway, thanks for sharing. Was hoping to read more.....positive or negative. At least can make informed decision. Glad your child found good friends and happy there......will make many of us more assured
-
breezy:
:goodpost:
Understand your concern but really, if u and your son like the program and the school environment feels good, go ahead with it.
To begin with, every sch (esp independent schools), have rich kids. It doesnt mean that rich kids would flaunt their wealth in schools.
It is a misconception that ACSI is flooded with such boys. The truth is that 10% of the boys are on Financial Assistance Scheme. My son goes to ACSI and he is in sec 3 IP now. He was from a neighbourhood primary school and we stay in HDB flat. Never once, did i hear him complain about his friend (may it be politician's or president's grandson, CEO's son...blabla) appearing proud or felt pressured to own a certain expensive gadget becos his friends have it.
His schoolmates are also very happy coming to my HDB home for stayovers and work on projects, etc. None of them appeared snobbish.
As for donations, it is on a volunteer basis. Once after chinese new year (the money collected will use to fund needy schoolmates for yearly overseas trip starting in secondary 2), the other sometime midyr.
Happy deciding! :))))
Also, the truth is the top IPs also have a higher percentage of parents of better backgrounds nowadays :nailbite: Expensive tuition requires deep pockets :evil: Majority of the rich kids do not brag but any casual/innocent comment by them on travelling or possessions may be misconstrued by the less rich as bragging. -
kwcllf:
SJI would start Year 5 IB in 2013 so by the time your DS goes to JC 1 / Year 5, there would be 4 cohorts of graduating students ahead of him.
You can read about the program in their school website. Recently, it was reportrd in the papers that they won some art-science competition. I think you can also read it in the website.Malsy9:
Hi does anyone have any information on SJI Ip
Program . DS not sure if he should take up program considering they are just starting IP this year . Anyone have any information would appreciate a lot . My son dream school is ACSI but reasons same as above not sure if he should go there .
Likewise they will start Year 3 IP in 2014 so your DS would benefit from the experience of their seniors.
http://www.sji.edu.sg/subpage.php?id=361 -
leeven:
Something about the green pants school openly solicts gifts from parents for its teachers which is also discuss in the other forum:
Kiasumeme, list the questions like below and answer yourself and ask your DS to answer which will lead u to what u want . This I have done my side which made me decide green pants and not white pants.kiasumeme:
I'm not sure if it is appropriate to place this query here but do really appreciate to hear some opinion. \"What would be your choice between SJI-IB vs HCI? SJI has projected a very convincing image that it is a school of character whilst the latter is a highly sought after, reputable institution with good track records.\"
1. Interest in Mother Tongue.
2. Do you want him to mingle with multi culture people or get taste of the tradition more.
3. CCA's and other clubs the school has that might interest your child and how high the chance to get what he wants to.
4. Your's child capacity and style of learning.
5. Relaxed phase / Non relaxed phase of learning.
6. IB is for about the Critical thinking & Management Skills and A-Level route dont have (unless the school has seperate pgms for these and your DS gets chance to participate)
7. Are you after branded name.
8. How much ure DS will have chance to participate in pgrms they have in the school , this is more important. school might have many things but if your DS didnt get chance then what is the point joing the school
http://www.kiasuparents.com/kiasu/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=40023 -
BeContented:
Understand your concern but really, if u and your son like the program and the school environment feels good, go ahead with it.breezy:
[quote=\"BeContented\"]Most of all, being amongst the rich would mean DS has to be very strong in his character, must be able to withstand the temptation, possible taunting (intentional/unintentional) from his peers etc. He will need to learn and I will need to manage his 'why others have, I can't :stompfeet:
To begin with, every sch (esp independent schools), have rich kids. It doesnt mean that rich kids would flaunt their wealth in schools.
It is a misconception that ACSI is flooded with such boys. The truth is that
10% of the boys are on Financial Assistance Scheme. My son goes to ACSI
and he is in sec 3 IP now. He was from a neighbourhood primary school and
we stay in HDB flat. Never once, did i hear him complain about his friend (may it be politician's or president's grandson, CEO's son...blabla) appearing
proud or felt pressured to own a certain expensive gadget becos his friends have it.
His schoolmates are also very happy coming to my HDB home for stayovers
and work on projects, etc. None of them appeared snobbish.
As for donations, it is on a volunteer basis. Once after chinese new year (the money collected will use to fund needy schoolmates for yearly overseas trip starting in secondary 2), the other sometime midyr.
Happy deciding! :))))
I also know not all are rich, but perhaps the ratio might be on the higher side hence this perception (plus people like us think think think then dare not go ACSI ....end up only rich ones went ahead to join :rotflmao: ) Anyway, it's all speculation
As for flaunting their wealth, guess I did mention that some are unintentional and sometimes, it's ourselves who gets sensitive/envious/jealous/upset cos cannot afford .... :oops: But I just wanted to highlight this aspect cos' it can get sticky if the child gets 'affected'. My DS is ok, but DD is one such gal who would whine over such
things....took a lot of effort to explain and discipline :frustrated: So must really depend on the child.
Anyway, thanks for sharing. Was hoping to read more.....positive or negative. At least can make informed decision. Glad your child found good friends and happy there......will make many of us more assured[/quote]
My nephew is in ACSI now and he is doing very well there. According to him, all his classmates stay in HDB flats except for two, one stays in a condo and the other in landed property. There aren't any 'Richie Rich' issues among the classmates and they learn and play with one another like good brothers. They even piggy back one another at times during their fun times.
ACSI has all along been branded with having the 'Richie Rich' boy mentality which I think is a misconception. With Singaporeans getting more and more affluent, even the average household can provide reasonably well for their kids and they are not lacking in their 'wants' except the few minority. So students should in no way feel inferior and be intimidated when faced with
their richer counterparts. What's important is our kids learn the importance of self-awareness, being able to feel good and proud of who they are and what they can be. They should learn to be resilient, adaptable and relate well to people from all walks of life and background, managing them with good EQ.
ACSI is a great school which has done very good jobs on character building in their students. I must say the school has produced many 'an officer and a gentleman' students all these years. -
Thank you parents .
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
Online Users
Recent Topics
Statistics