DSA 2011

[ngbrdad]

DVL:

ngbrdad:

The foreign students we are talking about in NUSH's case is those who flew in directly to take the selection test and camp .

They even make provision to these students that they can bring a dictionary to the first round test and they can appear in street clothes for the camp.

Just like to know is there any stat on how many are these students every year ?

Don't have the stats but during the matriculation at NUSH in Dec 2010, I recalled seeing only 2-3 kids in home clothes. DS is in NUSH Year 1, more than 30% of his classmates were not born in Singapore but all of them had their primary education here. Anyway, the number is not important, the crux of the matter is if these FTs are depriving our kids of a place and I believe the answer is no.

More accurate assessment should be how many of these are paying school fees at foreigner rate, how many at PR rate and how many at local rate.

[Blur Dad]

DVL:

ngbrdad:

The foreign students we are talking about in NUSH's case is those who flew in directly to take the selection test and camp .

They even make provision to these students that they can bring a dictionary to the first round test and they can appear in street clothes for the camp.

Just like to know is there any stat on how many are these students every year ?

Don't have the stats but during the matriculation at NUSH in Dec 2010, I recalled seeing only 2-3 kids in home clothes. DS is in NUSH Year 1, more than 30% of his classmates were not born in Singapore but all of them had their primary education here. Anyway, the number is not important, the crux of the matter is if these FTs are depriving our kids of a place and I believe the answer is no.

May I know base on what ground you said the answer is \"no\"?

[cestmoi]

Maisu:

My DD RGS via science, there r 8 questions, 1. About y gorillas have more facial expression than orang utang. 2. a bottle of perfume in the center of d room, with

two person at each end, y one can smell it when bottle opened n the other can't. 3. Y do athelatics train in the mountain? That's wat she could remember out of all. Two experiments, not easy, she told me but I still could not understand so not able to explain it here. Her selection date was 9 July but her school mate went on 23 July said it's the same questions n experiments.

Thanks Maisu for sharing! My DD schoolmate cld onli remember this : During one of the experiments, it was asked: what is the fastest way to burst a balloon...

SAME QUESTIONS & SAME EXPERIMENTS on 2 separate test dates!! Haiz! :gloomy:

[OrangeJuice]

cestmoi:

cestmoi:

[quote=\"OrangeJuice\"]
My DD went for Englsig domain test at RGS on 23/7, she told me groups are big and difficult to talk much. she said for poem appreciation, there were 18 of them so if you respond too slow, then you hv nothing to say because your ideas may be commented by girls who spoke up sooner...DD came home and told me she thinks she didnt do well for the poem appreciation section...now keeping my fingers crossed she did well in the other 2 sections

Hi Orange Juice
A few parents chatted after DD short break & this was what I heard :

A DD told that her grp was delayed in releasing for break maybe becos no one cld contribute very much in the poem & teacher had to wait very long for ppl to speak up.
Another DD said that her grp teacher had to stop one girl & told her that she was hogging the discussion.
My DD grp had 5 active ones during the poem discussion.

So dun worry too much as I am sure the other components can help ur DD.

I was also told that probably by next week (1st week of Aug) shortlisted applicants will be informed for interview which will likely be held on 2nd week of August.
Btw, did ur DD DSA other schs too?
In the meantime, lets all cross our fingers together & hope for the best! [/quote]Hi cestmoi,

thanks for your very comforting message

my DD also tried NYGH but her dream school is RGS and she badly wants to study there. Yes yes let's keep our fingers crossed and hope our DDs get into the final interview wishing our DDs good luck !

Just curious, I was reading some posts on the Science domain selection, wonder why the school used the same set of questions for different batch of girls taking the test on 2 different dates, would not that be unfair to the 1st batch as the questions may be leaked to the 2nd batch of girls who cld then find out answers to the secience questions asked ?

[DVL]

Blur Dad:

DVL:

[quote=\"ngbrdad\"]The foreign students we are talking about in NUSH's case is those who flew in directly to take the selection test and camp .

They even make provision to these students that they can bring a dictionary to the first round test and they can appear in street clothes for the camp.

Just like to know is there any stat on how many are these students every year ?

Don't have the stats but during the matriculation at NUSH in Dec 2010, I recalled seeing only 2-3 kids in home clothes. DS is in NUSH Year 1, more than 30% of his classmates were not born in Singapore but all of them had their primary education here. Anyway, the number is not important, the crux of the matter is if these FTs are depriving our kids of a place and I believe the answer is no.

May I know base on what ground you said the answer is \"no\"?[/quote]During last year DSA talk. the school told us that they would take in about 150 during the DSA phase and the remaining 10% will be kept for S1 posting. This year, the school has 140 Year 1 students. This means that the school can't even fill up their planned enrollment.

[kiasu1999]

any news from NYGH DAS (non-gep) apply?

[cestmoi]

OrangeJuice:

Hi cestmoi,

thanks for your very comforting message

my DD also tried NYGH but her dream school is RGS and she badly wants to study there. Yes yes let's keep our fingers crossed and hope our DDs get into the final interview wishing our DDs good luck !

Just curious, I was reading some posts on the Science domain selection, wonder why the school used the same set of questions for different batch of girls taking the test on 2 different dates, would not that be unfair to the 1st batch as the questions may be leaked to the 2nd batch of girls who cld then find out answers to the secience questions asked ?

My DD applied for NYGH too :rahrah: and like urs, DD & DH prefer RGS whilst I am on NYGH...well both has their own strengths...
Precisely, on the topic of same questions given on diff test dates, I had that same unfair feelings too! The 2nd batch applicants cld then come well prepared with answers... :siao: Wonder why the sch wld do that? :scratchhead:

[kiasu1999]

NYGH & RGS which is better?

[OrangeJuice]

cestmoi:

OrangeJuice:

[quote=\"cestmoi\"[quote=\"OrangeJuice\"]
Hi cestmoi,

thanks for your very comforting message

my DD also tried NYGH but her dream school is RGS and she badly wants to study there. Yes yes let's keep our fingers crossed and hope our DDs get into the final interview wishing our DDs good luck !

Just curious, I was reading some posts on the Science domain selection, wonder why the school used the same set of questions for different batch of girls taking the test on 2 different dates, would not that be unfair to the 1st batch as the questions may be leaked to the 2nd batch of girls who cld then find out answers to the secience questions asked ?

My DD applied for NYGH too :rahrah: and like urs, DD & DH prefer RGS whilst I am on NYGH...well both has their own strengths...
Precisely, on the topic of same questions given on diff test dates, I had that same unfair feelings too! The 2nd batch applicants cld then come well prepared with answers... :siao: Wonder why the sch wld do that? :scratchhead:[/quote]Is your DD a GEPer ?
Mine is from mainstream.

DH likes NYGH, DD likes RGS, I like NYGH because of its rich Chinese values but I also like RGS because I am an \"old-girl\" and loved my secondary schooldays there. Like what you said, they are both wonderful schools and DD will be a very lucky girl if either or both schools were to accept her. Now I can only pray for the best. I am grateful for this webiste where mommies and daddies are magnimous enough to share so much info. and encouragement

[i3mum]

Does anyone know if Girls brigade can be considered to apply for DSA? Any criteria needed?