ryka:Let me share my DC experience.
My DC is always an average or just slightly above average student in his MS primary school. He loves math and science subjects but his overall always being pulled down by his weakness in language subjects. I believe DC came to NUSH as one of their lowest PSLE scorer in his cohort (DC will not be able to enter any IP school with his PSLE score). Thus, our expectation for DC is simple, to stay afloat only in school.
Fortunately, for almost the past 2 years, we could see how DC blooms in NUSH. We witnessed that he grows from strength to strength with all the opportunities provided by the school. As highlighted by other forummer, small cohort in NUSH means more opportunities for students be it superior or just average students. If DC was to enter another traditional IP school which also gave him offer, likely he would be in the “last class” and we guessed opportunities would also be limited.
We viewed NUSH as a very fair school, did my DC got any acceleration last year? No. But we were satisfied, because they gave him a fair chance to take the test. He can’t pass the test because his standard not there yet.
This year DC managed to secure place for multiple Olympiad modules (he has to choose!), something that we never expect him to acheive just over a year ago. We could see that his placement in some Olympiad competition also improving, all of these we attributed to the guidance from the school teachers since DC has no tuition outside.
We have had similar experience. My DD came from a neighbourhood school, was slightly above average in primary school, strong in Math & Sci but weak in languages. She DSAed to NUSH and her PSLE score was also among the lowest in her cohort (low 25x). No external tuition. NUSH is indeed quite fair, she had no subject acceleration as she didn't clear the diagnostic test, but she was involved in a number of olympiads. She did fairly well in these olympiads, took a few NUS modules too, and had the opportunity to go for overseas exchange and competitions. I am quite sure NUSH was the right high school for her, she wouldn't have that much opportunities had she joined another school.
Of course one should have passion for Math & Sci when they choose this school. But not all continue to pursue STEM related fields. Besides the usual Medicine, Computing, Science, Engineering and Pharmacy. quite a number of her friends have enrolled in the following courses in Uni: Law, Economics, Psychology, Art/Media/Design, Architecture, Accountancy, Business etc.