[Bukit Timah] Primary Schools

[jeanieg]

Luanee:

Hi there!


From the past years stats for MGS under phase 2C:
2006 ballot 1-2 km
2007 ballot within 1km
2008 ballot 1-2 km
2009 ballot within 1km

Since you stay 1-2 km from MGS, you would surely end up balloting, or worst case, dont even get a chance to ballot at all.

My advice is go for 2B in CHIJ first. But u said above u have 2 girls borned in 2005 and 2004? If borned in 2004 then u be too late for PV application now. I assume it was a typo and ur girls were borned in 2005 and 2006 instead since u mentioned ur registration is in 2011? In that case u need to register as a PV latest by jun 2010. And pls, do call up the school NOW to check its PV application status, some schools may already started or even filled up all their PV slots for 2005 kids by now.

So pls act fast. As u urself probably know, getting into MGS under 2C when u stay 1-2km has only a verrrry slim chance. So pls do ur back-up plans fast.

And I think it be a good idea if u can submit ur PV application to Pei Hwa at the same time..

Hi Luanee

Thank you for your advice. Yes, it was a typo. Girls were born in 2005 and 2006... blur.

My concern with Pei Hwa is that I heard it is a very academic-driven school, stressing on good results, etc. True? If so don't think wanna put girls there that's why thought CHIJ OLQP is better, unless I am wrong about CHIJ...

[jeanieg]

titank:

It is best to check with all these schools whether is there a way to do PV a not. If no maybe you may want to try the RC route which is a 2nd alternative. By looking at your choice, all are quite popular schools.


Once you decided to participate in balloting it really depends on luck. If it turns out unsuccessful you would have to be in the Phase 2C supplementary. At phase 2C sub, most schools (In demand) would have already being taken up. Just to share with you a friend of mine in recent P1 registration the hard process she went through.

Day 1 – Submit in Rosyth School (She is more than 2Km)
Day 2 – Rosyth called her said she better withdraw as confirm no chance. She withdraw & register in CHIJ Nativity
Day 3 – Still safe as not many people register. At 4pm whole crowd of applicants (1km & 1-2Km) came in where she straight away game over. She simply had no time to run to other school to register.

Thank you for sharing. So if I volunteer with CHIJ and then apply under Phase 2B, if I do not get in I can then try MGS? Is there a way where I can register with CHIJ under Phase 2B and watch the situation in MGS and then last minute pull out of CHIJ and try MGS? Too risky? Or no such possibility?

[Buckbrick]

Hi Jeanieg, you can gauge your chances by looking at the ballot history in this forum (thanks to all the contributors for that!). http://www.kiasuparents.com/kiasu/content/singapore-primary-1-registration-school-balloting-history


You will see that there is balloting for MGS even in 2B for >2km in 09. That also means no problem for 1-2km folks. Who knows how it will be when it's your turn? On the other hand, CHIJ has no ballot in 2B. At least you won't have to worry your socks off, having spent those hours in pv.

Sorry to say but your stratgegy has to be the opposite. Coz by the time you get to 2c, you'll be right back to your problem: balloting at MGS and Pei Hwa. But I see that your chances are better at CHIJ, even in 2c.

[titank]

jeanieg:

titank:

It is best to check with all these schools whether is there a way to do PV a not. If no maybe you may want to try the RC route which is a 2nd alternative. By looking at your choice, all are quite popular schools.


Once you decided to participate in balloting it really depends on luck. If it turns out unsuccessful you would have to be in the Phase 2C supplementary. At phase 2C sub, most schools (In demand) would have already being taken up. Just to share with you a friend of mine in recent P1 registration the hard process she went through.

Day 1 – Submit in Rosyth School (She is more than 2Km)
Day 2 – Rosyth called her said she better withdraw as confirm no chance. She withdraw & register in CHIJ Nativity
Day 3 – Still safe as not many people register. At 4pm whole crowd of applicants (1km & 1-2Km) came in where she straight away game over. She simply had no time to run to other school to register.

Thank you for sharing. So if I volunteer with CHIJ and then apply under Phase 2B, if I do not get in I can then try MGS? Is there a way where I can register with CHIJ under Phase 2B and watch the situation in MGS and then last minute pull out of CHIJ and try MGS? Too risky? Or no such possibility?

Once you get into CHIJ at Phase 2B can already :celebrate: .
Don't need to go into Phase 2C as you very likey to face ballot & it is like :stupid:

[Luanee]

jeanieg:

Thank you for sharing. So if I volunteer with CHIJ and then apply under Phase 2B, if I do not get in I can then try MGS? Is there a way where I can register with CHIJ under Phase 2B and watch the situation in MGS and then last minute pull out of CHIJ and try MGS? Too risky? Or no such possibility?

U mean u want to withdraw after getting a place at CHIJ at 2B and ballot for MGS at 2C??? It is possible, but verrrrrrrrrrrrrrrry risky !!!!! Unless (which is quite low chance) during your year of registration, that everyone staying 1-2 km of MGS get in at 2C with no balloting required.

[sotongmom]

I count myself very blessed as I'm old gal of both pri schs and my kids are all set. I hv 2 gals and a boy (6, 4 and 2). I was going to send the gals to MGS and boy to NYPS but that means i hv to shuttle to 2 diff places when they are all in sch (still many years to go). Am I asking for trouble? :? :?

[tankee]

YES !!!

[Eagle-Ladybird]

They are not that far apart . . . or am i wrong ?

[BigDevil]

They are not that far apart, but…


Every morning I drop off DD at 7am at NYPS. Then I will proceed down Bukit Timah Road to get to work. So I have to first fight through traffic trying to go into HCI. Then when reaching MGS, I see another huge line of traffic trying to turn into MGS.

So yes, they are not that far apart, but it will take you a long time to get from NYPS to MGS. I imagine you might need to drop off the NYPS (and youngest!) boy before 7 so that your girls can be on time.

Why not consider putting all 3 in NYPS?

[mrswongtuition]

sotongmom:

I count myself very blessed as I'm old gal of both pri schs and my kids are all set. I hv 2 gals and a boy (6, 4 and 2). I was going to send the gals to MGS and boy to NYPS but that means i hv to shuttle to 2 diff places when they are all in sch (still many years to go). Am I asking for trouble? :? :?

I will personally do the same
Which is more impt? Convenient for you or a great school for your girls?
Hb & I hv already decided long ago if I have a girl, we'll hv the same arrangement as you. Whoever has more self-discipline will reach school first (so can go school early to read story book or ask teacher questions).