All About SAP Schools
-
My kids are in one of the SAP primary schools.
The option to take higher chinese is there when you are in SAP pri school and the points in higher chinese will only be taken into account if you apply for a SAP sec school, otherwise can’t use the marks.
I find that the emphasis and format of learning for higher chinese is different from the CL2 chinese. So if your child has no aptitude for mother tongue, then it may be wiser to drop the higher mother tongue and concentrate on the 2nd language which is to be counted in the PSLE. -
Hi,
My neighourhood primary school conducted Higher Chinese from P5 onwards. At P6 level (this year), we had 4.5 hours for Chinese and 1.5 hours for Higher Chinese. The teacher that taught us Higher Chinese and Chinese happened to be the same person.
The main reason as to why I chose Higher Chinese was because I thought that Higher Chinese might improve my Chinese to gain a decent PSLE aggregate T-Score. I didn't intend to use Higher Chinese as a route to score bonus points when applying for SAP secondary schools.
Most students and parents think it is easily to score in Chinese based on past PSLE statistical figures :
National Average (A* & A)
2008 - 81.4 %
2007 - 81.1 %
2006 - 81.0 %
2005 - 80.9 %
2004 - 79.4 %
To some extent, this mindset is true depending on whether you had achieved A* or A in PSLE Chinese. In actual fact, my teacher told us that it was tough to score A* in PSLE Chinese and this A* will greatly helped the student to improve his/her PSLE T-score. Personally, I felt this truly applied to PSLE 2008.My classmates that had scored A* in Chinese were better in aggregate PSLE T-scores than those that had scored A* in the other three subjects.
IMHO, this may substantiate the core reason as to why most students appeared to have scored better in SAP schools than neighbourhood schools for aggregate PSLE T-scores.

-
Hi Vanilla Cake
Did u come from a neighbourhood SAP primary school? I am confused as I thought only SAP primary schools offer higher chinese? If not so, then what is the definition of a SAP primary school? -
Imp75:
Hi Imp75,Hi Vanilla Cake
Did u come from a neighbourhood SAP primary school? I am confused as I thought only SAP primary schools offer higher chinese? If not so, then what is the definition of a SAP primary school?
I came from a neighbourhood non-SAP primary school.From P1 to P4, I took Normal Chinese.I only studied Higher Chinese at P5 and P6.4.5 hours for Normal Chinese & 1.5 hours for Higher Chinese per week in school.
Sorry, I am not sure what is the definition of a SAP primary school.
Perhaps our Kiasu Chief can explain as he has kids in Kong Hwa or other parents that have kids in SAP schools.
Warmest regards. -
Imp75:
Extracted from one website :Hi Vanilla Cake
Did u come from a neighbourhood SAP primary school? I am confused as I thought only SAP primary schools offer higher chinese? If not so, then what is the definition of a SAP primary school?
\"If your child is taking Chinese language, you may also wish to consider the 15 SAP primary schools which offer Higher Chinese from Primary 1. These schools aim to promote the Chinese language and culture in students from a young age. The schools are:
Ai Tong School
Catholic High School
CHIJ St Nicholas Girls' School
Holy Innocents’ Primary School
Hong Wen School
Kong Hwa School
Maha Bodhi School
Maris Stella High School
Nan Hua Primary School
Nanyang Primary School
Pei Chun Publis School
Pei Hwa Presbyterian Primary Poi Ching School
Red Swastika School
Tao Nan School
Students of the Special Assistance Plan (SAP) schools can look forward to more opportunities to deepen their learning of the Chinese Language (CL) and culture as the SAP schools will be introducing enhancements to their programmes.
SAP schools were first established in 1979 to preserve the ethos of the Chinese medium schools and to promote the learning of Chinese Language and culture. \"
NON-SAP schools also offer Higher Chinese for students in pr 5 & 6 who score Band 1 for Chinese in P4 Exams.
However, I understand that some students in SAP schools can opt out of the Higher Chinese programme in Pr 6 if they cannot cope with it. My friend's son is one example.
Hope it helps. -
If I understand correctly, putting aside the non-quantifiable stuff like culture/enrichment, the stark difference between SAP and non-SAP is the introduction of HML in P1 for SAP vz P5 for non-SAP (band 1 students)?
-
Imp75:
If I understand correctly, putting aside the non-quantifiable stuff like culture/enrichment, the stark difference between SAP and non-SAP is the introduction of HML in P1 for SAP vz P5 for non-SAP (band 1 students)?
I used to hear that this was the differentiation. But recently I came to know that non-SAP schools also offered HCL to their students after P1 for those who showed potential in Chinese eg. my dd's school. Also I was even more surprised to know that SAP kids can opt out from HCL at any point of time other than the designated P5 level eg, my neighbour's dd's school. So it seems that there is really no difference now. Anyone has the same experience? -
[quote]NON-SAP schools also offer Higher Chinese for students in pr 5 & 6 who score Band 1 for Chinese in P4 Exams.
However, I understand that some students in SAP schools can opt out of the Higher Chinese programme in Pr 6 if they cannot cope with it. My friend's son is one example.
Hope it helps.[/quote]It's true that non-sap schools HCL to students in P5 onwards, however, some schools do prep the students who are good in CL since P2 for HCL.
SAP schools have HCL since P1, even if they are not good at it, they will be stuck with it till end P4, then can choose to opt mainstream CL from P5 onwards. Most of the time, parents will opt for HCL tho some of these kids score only 60+. Some SAP schools will not reject students who score lower than B1 in HCL at P4 even if they opt for HCL too in P5.
Personally, I feel that HCL from P1 is good cos it builds up the kids' confidence in CL and creates a good base and foundation for higher level. But of cos if the child is weak in CL, then it may affect them when they are banded in classes based on results cos main core subjects are accounted for banding to better classes in school. -
ks2me:
But recently I came to know that non-SAP schools also offered HCL to their students after P1 for those who showed potential in Chinese eg. my dd's school.
My nephew is going to a non-sap school, but my sis said they have higher chinese text book in their P1 booklist. :?: -
so i guess non-sap schs are also getting competitive. They are going to prove more to parents out there. So they offer HCL to pupils, but I am not sure how they are going about doing it. Gonna ask some of my ex-colleagues who are teaching in non-sap schools soon.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login8
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects