How to work with insolent children
-
kiasimom:
:goodpost: EXACTLY my sentiments!I take it that it is healthy for a child to talk back.
I will first determine the reason why he talks back.
I will listen to him and I will then analyse why he talks back.
I don't advocate the idea that as parents we are always right.
The child should have a mind of his own and be encouraged to speak up on what is in his mind.
I don't want to raise a robot who will only listens to instructions but deprive of his thinkings and mindset.
As long as my child is not rude, it may be a positive thing for him to reason with me.
It shows that he has the ability to analyse. -
kiasimom:
You are right, but usually they are downright rude & showed lack of respect !!
As long as my child is not rude, it may be a positive thing for him to reason with me.
It shows that he has the ability to analyse.
What do you do then ? -
VitoRelax:
Tell them \"I say no/so\"...then when both are calmer, talk this through.
You are right, but usually they are downright rude & showed lack of respect !!kiasimom:
As long as my child is not rude, it may be a positive thing for him to reason with me.
It shows that he has the ability to analyse.
What do you do then ?
I've always cajoled and even plead and this year (okay, okay, it's Feb liao), I told myself, enough is enough...today at the shop when she dilly-dallied and started to talk back when I told her to hurry up and choose her product, she started getting rude.
I told her, \"okay, in that case we're not getting XXX.\" in my sternest voice; and then the shoplady (obviously NOT a parent) commented out loud, \"wah, you so strict ah\" :roll:
Sometimes, we just have to seize the moment and show DD/DS that we are serious...next time, it'd get easier coz she/he would think twice in being rude and answering back just for the sake of answering back; and in testing limits.
All the best! -
Sigh. I read backwards on this thread and it offers such a wealth of wisdom.
Hugs to you, Andiaz, I know how it feels. If the incident is isolated, it'd be ok to close one eye. But if your DD is heading towards preteendom or already in the throes of it, I gather it's gonna be awhile.
Anyway, I was locked in a power struggle with my son last week and it wasn't a pretty sight :(. We've always been laissez faire at home cos DS is a prize fighter cock, and fighting with him trains him to be even better. He knows the rules - as long as it's reasonable and he argues without being rude or throwing a tantrum, we'll generally compromise. He's usually a sweet kid albeit with a sharp tongue.
Anyway, suffice to say, there's a new stressor - homework. I went from being gently persuasive to snarling witch after two weeks. When that didn't work, my inital move was to get even harsher - punishment by docking pocket money (he got ruder by the day), but the response was
for me!
The net result though, is that we both learnt. He says he'll finish up homework in school where he can, and he's been exemplary the last few days, and me, I've reverted to being my persuasive, supportive self.
Maybe these one-off tightening of the screws will have to happen to \"reset\" the settings once in a while, and the trick is to make it as painlesss as possible while delivering the message and waiting for the negtive behaviour to subside. Will have to think of how. Anyone has ideas?? :?: -
There are certain things in my house that will be non negotiable. And when it come to enforcing such things, I will be totally autocratic. For example, 1st thing to do when you wake up is to wash up. No reading, no TV, no games 1st, brush teeth, wash up, breakfast before anything else. I don’t care if it’s a school day or a weekend or holidays. When my kids ask why, my answer to them is this is basic hygiene and it is also the way I want it to be, no need to ask why. Next time when you have your own house you can set your own rules. So bad hor.
DD started behaving in a very diao man manner last week. She never behaved like that in the past. She will cross her arms and stamp her feet and say things like, I want it now means now. Then go huffing and puffing and sit down at the sofa to sulk. 1st time, I ignored her. But the 2nd time, I told her to get her butt off the couch and come to me. And she did, but still with her crossed arms and stamping feet. So I warned her and told her to stop her arms crossing and stamping and saying things like want it now means now. No raised voices just low serious tones telling her how disappointed and sad I am to see my girl behaving like a brat. Then I told her to go reflect on her behaviour. When she has sorted out her thinking she can come and talk to me. It took all of 3 mins and she came to me with tears in her eyes and an apology. That was when we revisit the original topic of what she wanted in the first place and worked out a compromise.
I know that her insisting on having her way without hearing me out or explaining to me why she wants it that way could be an imitation of my no negotiation attitude towards some stuff. But just as mummy here is learning what makes them tick and what methods work best with them, they are also learning what method works best with mummy. -
Hello
May I know how do u deal with kid that like to talk back?
Am pretty frustrated these days wif my girl.
I was coaching her on her work earlier, and waiting for her to finish,I was looking at the computer for some info.I hurried her.Guess how she talked back?You are looking at your computer what…I got pissed off and I told her off, am wasting my time, sitting next to her waiting for her to finish a piece of her work.She is not indept, if am not there, she will wonder away, catching ends, drawing etc…
thanks -
how old is this daughter?
-
primary 5
tankee:
how old is this daughter?
-
Lynn2:
My DS also P5, he has mild-ADHD, also similar kind of attitude, dealing with him is blood vomiting at times... he has selective independency, ie: independent in HW with the subjects he is interested (Math and Science), he will also talks back. Especially Chinese! Sigh...Hello
May I know how do u deal with kid that like to talk back?
Am pretty frustrated these days wif my girl.
I was coaching her on her work earlier, and waiting for her to finish,I was looking at the computer for some info.I hurried her.Guess how she talked back?You are looking at your computer what...I got pissed off and I told her off, am wasting my time, sitting next to her waiting for her to finish a piece of her work.She is not indept, if am not there, she will wonder away, catching ends, drawing etc...
thanks
I understand kids at this age is experiencing hormone changes, due to beginning stage of puberty. So we need to learn to tolerate their nonsense... -
I think children pick up habits from people around them, they could be children from school, people at home etc.
Hence, I make an effort to explain to my dd (pri 2) whenever I notice bad attitude from her. It is easy for her to change to the better at her age.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login10
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects