[PSLE MT] PSLE less weightage in Chinese / Mother Tongue
-
ks2me:
But if we have more and more potato parents, how do such schools survive? Demand and supply will kick in sometime...
then less competition for places in sap school, better for the lao bai xin. eventually, it will be those truly bilingual people who will have more opportunities open to them
look at some asean countries where they emphasise race & language supremacy ..... where are they ? -
I agree with you but I hope there are no backlashes…if they insist their way
-
HyperKiasu:
No. I am Non-SAP school parents. I want a change, I am considering transfer my son to a SAP school.....
No, my child is not in a SAP school too and she's only taking normal chinese.
I just don't see how reducing the weightage of MTL in PSLE will be beneficial to our children in the long run. -
lego:
拭目以待, 哈哈.....No, my child is not in a SAP school too and she's only taking normal chinese.
I just don't see how reducing the weightage of MTL in PSLE will be beneficial to our children in the long run. -
vlim:
If we are talking about our generation and perhaps one more generation, then there may be no impact yet. Beyond that if they grow up in new system where MT is not an emphasis and they themselves have no ability to enforce that with their children, naturally it would cascade the effect down the generation. As it is now, I have been hearing people saying their mother tongue is English due to such parents they have. In future such parents would be even more...
but I think otherwise, as I think parents get to know the importance of mastering Chinese Language (with this current system) so I think more and more parents will choose SAP school for their kids so that they will have a better chinese language foundation..
Btw, I am not as optimistic as you also because I believe the competitive landscape in Singapore is real, everyone wants a pie in the academic race so in the end, the not-so-important subjects will be sidelined, like it or not. In fact if they emphasized on CCA, CCA may even precede learning Chinese.... *sigh* Majority will play the rules of the game to stay relevant. -
BlackAngel:
wondering whether this is true..... :?
It is a form of elitism by a small group of parents who has been pressurising the government. ...... -
tamarind:
I totally agree that it is very important that the Chinese teacher knows the correct method, and knows how to develop interest in learning the language. My DS used to attend some Chinese enrichment courses where the native Chinese teachers teach all the kids 'one level' up, ie. for P1, they teach P2 stuff and for P2, they teach P3 stuff etc. They said S'pore standard is one level 'lower' as compared to their country and therefore it is good that they learn 'in advance'. But for kids who do not have a strong foundation during their kindy years, it is actually very tough to 'catch-up' with their kind of syllabus. It actually kills the interest rather than motivate them towards that language. Subsequently I realised that many tuition centres are doing the same...Even some schools have rather 'tough' standards from what I can see in their past exam qns. I'm definitely no expert in Chinese but I'm able to converse and even write in Chinese with my China and Taiwan colleagues without problems or miscommunication, isn't that sufficient? I'm personally not in favour of reducing the weightage, but rather, I hope something can be done to motivate the kids to want to do better in the language, rather then 'putting them off' by trying to level them with the standards of those from Chinese speaking countries...My daughter also told me that she enjoys her Chinese lesson more than English and Maths. It is very important that the Chinese teacher knows the correct methods of teaching the language, and knows how to develop interest, rather than simply following the textbook. The primary school Chinese textbooks are very bad. Kids who do not have a good foundation in Chinese before entering primary school, will not be able to learn well from these textbooks.
MOE should focus on understanding what are the correct and effective methods of learning Chinese, rather than trying to lower the weightage of Chinese.
The best way to build a strong foundation in Chinese, is simply to read as many Chinese books as possible from a very young age. Many mommies have been reading English books to their kids since they were babies. If they have read the same amount of Chinese books to their kids, pointing to every word as they read, the kids will be equally good in Chinese too.
As for those people who keep complaining that Chinese is difficult, or that their brains are not hardwired to learn Chinese, they can always drop Chinese, like one parent wrote earlier.
I think that one way is to stop using the combined aggregate score as a cut off point for entering the top schools. Students will be given their exact scores in each subject. Schools can pick the type of students that they want, for example, some schools may take those who are very good in English and Maths, and ignore Chinese. Other schools may take those who are very good in languages, and ignore Maths. Something like the admission to the different courses in polytechnics. Chinese is not required for most courses, and maths is not important for some courses. -
I believe that MOE might be misled by a vocal group of parents who wanted things in their ways. For us, we tried our best to communicate with our child in both languages, read story books for them in 2 languages. we tried hard for these years, knowing the importance of both languages. Then suddenly, MOE announced chinese weighing cut?
What kind of signal is MOE sending to future parents? I think we as young parents need to think about it and not let MOE send us the wrong signal. Our child should not be swayed by these frequent change. Only hope that other young parents would be like most of us, trying hard to inculcate good chinese values through language to other child. Alas, MOE is controlled by Kantangs. -
My husband is a true-blue potato. He hates Chinese to the core and that is the result of the numerous lousy Chinese teachers and lessons he had when he was schooling. But even then, he recognises the importance of our children mastering the language because of the current PSLE weightage which I felt is a blessing in disguise as he is the one who insists on having the kids go for tuition and must get the best tutor for Chinese. With that I do not have to worry about my kids becoming so adverse to Chinese as he is.
Now with the shift in the weightage, I can just imagine the smirk on his face and him not being vigilant on the kids’ mastery of the Chinese Language anymore. sigh…it is indeed a bad move by MOE!!! -
Dear grandpas, grandmas, pas and mas
every year, hordes of students apply for prestigious scholarships and renowned secondary schools and JCs. many of them do well not only in math, sci, eng, humanities but also their mother tongues. a large number of them even have excellent grades in 3rd language! :!:
besides academics, there have sports captains, music talents, and even budding artists, just to name a few, till the providers are spoilt for choice! they are superb all-rounders till the institutions do not know how to choose the best among the best!
therefore, in their selection criteria, I think and I believe that they base their selection largely on the candidate's personality as well, such as their strength in characters and strength in mind. of course, among the many qualities, they may look for those like determination, perseverance and never-say-die attitude which will help them overcome challenges and tackle problems. this is essential to them and every personal being.
that said, it becomes much clearer who is indeed deserving of a place/scholarship and other opportunities
ps. please do not be overly worried or concerned. if your grandson/granddaughter/son/daughter truly has what it takes, providers and institutions will all be rushing to offer him/her a place or a scholarship. he/she may not even need to apply. they will love to have him/her!
from the point of view of me
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login