All About GEP
-
ChiefKiasu:
My girl's primary school still conduct exams at P1. They changed the name from exam to Semestral Assessment on the paper, but the teacher still call it exam. I think schools will continue to do what they think is \"necessary\" instead of following strictly to MOE guidelines.
How effective are the measures by the ministry to transform our education, without changing the legacy assessment methods by which we rank our children? The GEP is seen as a fast-track to elite Secondary schools coveted by parents so much so that they try to train their children to excel in the GEP selection tests. The IP schools are now coveted by parents because they are seen as the warranty of a place in the Universities. The \"teach less, learn more\" principle is thought of by parents as the schools telling us to give our kids more tuition because teachers no longer provide the answers, which are necessary so that our kids can ace their examinations!
I salute Mr Ng not just for recognising this conundrum, but also having the courage to initiate changes. The removal of examinations for P1 and P2 is a great start. Unfortunately, the public furore over the attempt to tweak PSLE weightage shows how difficult it is for anyone to change status quo, even if it may have resulted in a less stressful and better learning environment for our children. I pray that this setback will not diminish the MOE's efforts in continuing to tweak our education system to prepare our children for the uncertain future.
I will support any change of assessment methods, provided it is done fairly. It should not be changed for mother tongue only in order to make it easier to pass.
I will also support MOE if they decide to scrap the GEP and IP schools. There were no such things when I grew up and my generation of people are doing perfectly fine now. In fact, I am more worried about the kids who are stressed at such a young age. Especially those supposedly gifted ones, now made to study only for perfect scores. -
tamarind:
same with my boy's school. He told me: \"this week is very important leh, it is exam week....\"
My girl's primary school still conduct exams at P1. They changed the name from exam to Semestral Assessment on the paper, but the teacher still call it exam. I think schools will continue to do what they think is \"necessary\" instead of following strictly to MOE guidelines.tamarind:
Yes, the kids are stressed at a relatively younger age...two round of national test/exam (GEP selection test at age 9 and PSLE at age 12)I will support any change of assessment methods, provided it is done fairly. It should not be changed for mother tongue only in order to make it easier to pass.
I will also support MOE if they decide to scrap the GEP and IP schools. There were no such things when I grew up and my generation of people are doing perfectly fine now. In fact, I am more worried about the kids who are stressed at such a young age. Especially those supposedly gifted ones, now made to study only for perfect scores.
Perhaps singapore is little red dots with no natural resources, so goverment is also kiasu and can't help waiting to uncover talents/gifted (the only valuble assets that they own) at early age. -
HyperKiasu:
What's so stressful about GEP selection test? That's not a national exam. It's not even compulsory to take
Yes, the kids are stressed at a relatively younger age...two round of national test/exam (GEP selection test at age 9 and PSLE at age 12) -
phankao:
Agree. Self-induced stress lah... :lol:
What's so stressful about GEP selection test? That's not a national exam. It's not even compulsory to takeHyperKiasu:
Yes, the kids are stressed at a relatively younger age...two round of national test/exam (GEP selection test at age 9 and PSLE at age 12) -
tamarind:
I will also support MOE if they decide to scrap the GEP and IP schools. .... In fact, I am more worried about the kids who are stressed at such a young age.
I disagree with u on this point.
I currently hv 1 kid in IP n another in GEP.
They are both enjoying their schools and their curriculum.
The younger one seemed bored when he was in the lower primaries;
now he enjoys his lessons much better in GEP.
The IP curriculum allows the time saved from preparation for O levels
to be channelled into other meaningful activities in school to
nurture them holistically.
In fact, both of them seemed so easy going that I am the one
who becomes concerned!
Ha, maybe its their honeymoon year! :lol:
But we :offtopic: here liao. :lol: -
csc:
Agree. Self-induced stress lah... :lol:[/quote]All stress is self-induced, right? including those for PSLE....
What's so stressful about GEP selection test? That's not a national exam. It's not even compulsory to takephankao:
[quote=\"HyperKiasu\"]
Yes, the kids are stressed at a relatively younger age...two round of national test/exam (GEP selection test at age 9 and PSLE at age 12) -
phankao:
What's so stressful about GEP selection test? That's not a national exam. It's not even compulsory to takeHyperKiasu:
Yes, the kids are stressed at a relatively younger age...two round of national test/exam (GEP selection test at age 9 and PSLE at age 12)
yes, it is optional. If you read other thread about GEP, you will understand why it is stress.... -
HyperKiasu:
What's so stressful about GEP selection test? That's not a national exam. It's not even compulsory to takephankao:
[quote=\"HyperKiasu\"]
Yes, the kids are stressed at a relatively younger age...two round of national test/exam (GEP selection test at age 9 and PSLE at age 12)
yes, it is optional. If you read other thread about GEP, you will understand why it is stress....[/quote]There is nothing stressful abt it. There is no need to prepare for GEP selection test at all. If your kid can get in great, if not, just move on - getting into GEP is no big deal anyway. -
keroppi:
Actually, I have the same thinking too. If a kid is really gifted, no need to push, no need to put in extra effort, he/she is naturally gifted. Its naturally inside him/her, not tailored to be one.
There is nothing stressful abt it. There is no need to prepare for GEP selection test at all. If your kid can get in great, if not, just move on - getting into GEP is no big deal anyway.
-
tamarind:
My girl's primary school still conduct exams at P1. They changed the name from exam to Semestral Assessment on the paper, but the teacher still call it exam. I think schools will continue to do what they think is \"necessary\" instead of following strictly to MOE guidelines.ChiefKiasu:
How effective are the measures by the ministry to transform our education, without changing the legacy assessment methods by which we rank our children? The GEP is seen as a fast-track to elite Secondary schools coveted by parents so much so that they try to train their children to excel in the GEP selection tests. The IP schools are now coveted by parents because they are seen as the warranty of a place in the Universities. The \"teach less, learn more\" principle is thought of by parents as the schools telling us to give our kids more tuition because teachers no longer provide the answers, which are necessary so that our kids can ace their examinations!
I salute Mr Ng not just for recognising this conundrum, but also having the courage to initiate changes. The removal of examinations for P1 and P2 is a great start. Unfortunately, the public furore over the attempt to tweak PSLE weightage shows how difficult it is for anyone to change status quo, even if it may have resulted in a less stressful and better learning environment for our children. I pray that this setback will not diminish the MOE's efforts in continuing to tweak our education system to prepare our children for the uncertain future.
I will support any change of assessment methods, provided it is done fairly. It should not be changed for mother tongue only in order to make it easier to pass.
I will also support MOE if they decide to scrap the GEP and IP schools. There were no such things when I grew up and my generation of people are doing perfectly fine now. In fact, I am more worried about the kids who are stressed at such a young age. Especially those supposedly gifted ones, now made to study only for perfect scores.
Note that I was responding to ChiefKiasu's post, read his statement in bold.
Yes it is true not all kids will be selected to take the GEP selection test.
While some kids enjoy GEP, there are many other kids who are being pressurized by their parents to study very hard in order to pass the GEP selection tests. I believe that every bright kid will be told to study hard in order to be selected to take the test.
I walked pass Morris Allen recently, they had a 10 day GEP preparation course that charges $888 :!: And parents are willing to pay !
The worst is those kids who studied so hard, took the GEP selection test, but did not pass the test. Imagine feeling like a failure for the rest of his life, at 9 years old.
Off topic liao.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better š
Register Login