7 New IP schools
-
verykiasu2010:
That only shows three points which one of them must be correctWeiHan:
These new IP schools have a few independent schools and their students typically do not qualify for the MOE scholarship accordingly to psle score. By approving these expensive independent schools but not other \"cheaper\" government schools but of comparable academic standard, wouldn't the government be perceived of benefiting the richer elites more?
don't think so
government schools have been lacking in certain areas of school management ability (except for RI / RGS which are independently managed byt gov't funded). i dare not mention other names here. if you are free, go browse those threads on Sec 1 DSA for certain government schools and compare with those government-aided schools ....and you will see the difference based on parents discussions
hence to approve who for IP application must certainly look into whether the schools are ready in terms of ability to manage, and whether they have the resources to manage.
if you compare St Nick / MGS with say SMSS or BPGH...there is still a big gap. Having ambition to become an IP is one big step of faith on the part of the principal to begin with
1. The government has send lesser quality management staffs to government schools.
2. MOE centralised managment of our education system has room for improvement.
3. MOE did not provide government schools with equivalent resource which like first point that our government is elitist.
Moreover, you miss my point. Certain schools being better managed than government schools didn't disqualify my point that it benefits richer people more. -
Sorry for jumping in here. Have been reading the posts :-). It is not that MOE has not invested the resources in govt schools. Some schools with long history have strong support from their alumni. Popular schools attract students from better family backgrounds and the parents are very supportive of the schools. Influential alumni and parents help to lobby for what they want :-). This is something that most govt schools are lacking in. Being a principal of a popular school is not easy. Have to manage the expectations of all the stakeholders.
Strange that still no news online…waiting for the evening news now… -
WeiHan:
government aided schools are helped very much by their board of governors / directors / alumni and management committee (some are descendants of the school founders)....purely government schools do not have such - you are just not born with it.
That only shows three points which one of them must be correct
1. The government has send lesser quality management staffs to government schools.
2. MOE centralised managment of our education system has room for improvement.
3. MOE did not provide government schools with equivalent resource which like first point that our government is elitist.
Moreover, you miss my point. Certain schools being better managed than government schools didn't disqualify my point that it benefits richer people more.
I don't disqualify your point.
RI / RGS / RGPS being government schools also benefit many many and a lot of rich people wat ....on the other hand, poor people also can go to those government-aided schools wat and benefit from their system, who is stopping you ? remember, at Sec school, the posting is not distance based any more - it is ability based - based on the national placement exam called PSLE -
zeemimi:
Just wondering if they are ready to implement it so soon. Else by then the current Sec 1 & 2 have turn sec 3 & 4 to prepare for 'O' level liao.
Every sch has its own merits. We should cheer for 7 new IP schs, giving our next batch of P6 more choices. Hopefully the current Sec 1 and 2s can benefit too. -
The 2010 School achievement Table for Special/Express Course (like this http://www.moe.gov.sg/media/press/files/2009/09/moa-2009-annex-e1.pdf) based on individual school's academic performance in 2009 \"O\" level exams has not been released yet. However, you may look at some of these schools' websites to find their banding status, so these are the schools that attained Band 1 (Ave L1B5 less 11) for last year's \"O\" level results (2009) so far:
Based on 2009 \"O\" level results
1. Anderson Sec - 10.4
2. Catholic High - 9.1 / 343 candidates
3. Crescent Girls' - Don't know
4. Nan Chiau High - 10.9
5. St. Joseph Institution - 10.8
6. Victoria Sch - 10.7
There maybe more than the above mentioned 6 schools like Cedar Girls, St Nicholas Girls, SCGS, MGS etc that had attained band 1 status and so pls wait for MOE to release the official school achievement table 2010.
Based on \"O\" level results from 2003 to 2008 with schools that had attained band 1 status
Cedar: 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008
CHIJ St Nic: 2003, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008
SCGS: 2003, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008
Anglican High : 2004
Catholic High: 2004, 2006, 2007, 2008
Victoria: 2004, 2006, 2007, 2008
Anderson: 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008
Crescent Girls: 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008
Xinmin: 2005, 2006, 2007
Chung Cheng High (Main): 2006
MGS: 2006, 2007, 2008
SJI: 2007, 2008
TKGS: 2007, 2008
Zhonghua: 2007
Bukit Panjang Govt High: 2008
Pls help to correct the above list if any errors.
VC's mum -
alng:
exactlySorry for jumping in here. Have been reading the posts :-). It is not that MOE has not invested the resources in govt schools. Some schools with long history have strong support from their alumni. Popular schools attract students from better family backgrounds and the parents are very supportive of the schools. Influential alumni and parents help to lobby for what they want :-). This is something that most govt schools are lacking in. Being a principal of a popular school is not easy. Have to manage the expectations of all the stakeholders.
Strange that still no news online.....waiting for the evening news now....
you said it very well -
ApronMama:
no worry, can also enter IP at sec 3 ..... just produce good result, and doors will open
Just wondering if they are ready to implement it so soon. Else by then the current Sec 1 & 2 have turn sec 3 & 4 to prepare for 'O' level liao.zeemimi:
Every sch has its own merits. We should cheer for 7 new IP schs, giving our next batch of P6 more choices. Hopefully the current Sec 1 and 2s can benefit too.
therefore cannot sleep / play for 3 years then cheong one year for O levels -
ApronMama:
Since they annouce now... current sec2 will also be offered....otherwise why annoce now
Just wondering if they are ready to implement it so soon. Else by then the current Sec 1 & 2 have turn sec 3 & 4 to prepare for 'O' level liao.zeemimi:
Every sch has its own merits. We should cheer for 7 new IP schs, giving our next batch of P6 more choices. Hopefully the current Sec 1 and 2s can benefit too. -
verykiasu2010:
Hi,
government aided schools are helped very much by their board of governors / directors / alumni and management committee (some are descendants of the school founders)....purely government schools do not have such - you are just not born with it.WeiHan:
That only shows three points which one of them must be correct
1. The government has send lesser quality management staffs to government schools.
2. MOE centralised managment of our education system has room for improvement.
3. MOE did not provide government schools with equivalent resource which like first point that our government is elitist.
Moreover, you miss my point. Certain schools being better managed than government schools didn't disqualify my point that it benefits richer people more.
I don't disqualify your point.
RI / RGS / RGPS being government schools also benefit many many and a lot of rich people wat ....
I hope by giving an example, you can see my point more clearly.
For example, I score 252 for my psle. Clearly, I do not qualify for RGS or NYGH or DHS or even RV.
With these second batches of approved IP schools, I stand a better chance of enjoying IP. However, these are independent schools which demand a high school fees and I cannot afford. Neither is my result good enough to get a MOE scholarship which require aggregate of 262 or 263. I'll have to choose Nan Hua, CGS instead which did not get IP status because of my financial disadvantage. My classmate who also score 252 but has a rich daddy is considering joining MGS or SCGS. I am so disappointed.... -
Vanilla Cake:
Thanks VC's mum for the research.The 2010 School achievement Table for Special/Express Course (like this http://www.moe.gov.sg/media/press/files/2009/09/moa-2009-annex-e1.pdf) based on individual school's academic performance in 2009 \"O\" level exams has not been released yet. However, you may look at some of these schools' websites to find their banding status, so these are the schools that attained Band 1 (Ave L1B5 less 11) for last year's \"O\" level results (2009) so far:
Based on 2009 \"O\" level results
1. Anderson Sec - 10.4
2. Catholic High - 9.1 / 343 candidates
3. Crescent Girls' - Don't know
4. Nan Chiau High - 10.9
5. St. Joseph Institution - 10.8
6. Victoria Sch - 10.7
There maybe more than the above mentioned 6 schools like Cedar Girls, St Nicholas Girls, SCGS, MGS etc that had attained band 1 status and so pls wait for MOE to release the official school achievement table 2010.
Based on \"O\" level results from 2003 to 2008 with schools that had attained band 1 status
Cedar: 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008
CHIJ St Nic: 2003, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008
SCGS: 2003, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008
Anglican High : 2004
Catholic High: 2004, 2006, 2007, 2008
Victoria: 2004, 2006, 2007, 2008
Anderson: 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008
Crescent Girls: 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008
Xinmin: 2005, 2006, 2007
Chung Cheng High (Main): 2006
MGS: 2006, 2007, 2008
SJI: 2007, 2008
TKGS: 2007, 2008
Zhonghua: 2007
Bukit Panjang Govt High: 2008
Pls help to correct the above list if any errors.
VC's mum
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login5
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects