Choosing and Evaluating Primary Schools

[Funz]

Luanee, I have applied for PV for all these few schools along with HPPS but no luck. That’s why now exploring moving to within 1km of one of these schools. I thought so too that PHPPS will give me the best chance but somehow, this year’s registration there was balloting required for those within 1km. I think it is due to all the new condos coming up in that area.


Busymom, I did not include HPPS though it was my first choice for PV cos I saw the balloting history, practically every year balloting required for within 1km and highly over subscribed.

Decided to include NYP cos thot if move around that area oso more convenient for DD if DS gets in, since both are nearby.

As for ACS Primary, well my Dad was an old boys, unfortunately, tak pakay. I was looking at the balloting history of ACS and it seems they have a cut off the last 2 years. Don’t understand how this cut off thing works though. Problem is the vacancy for 2C is very low since majority of the space is taken up by alumni and church members.

Can someone explain what that cut off means?

After looking and looking and comparing, I thought ACS might accord a higher chance since it is a boy’s school and population density is lower. That is if by cut off they mean they number of registrants equal vacancy without any manipulation done.

And if I balloting within 1km is involved, I think ACS and NYPS will accord higher chances since the last 2 years, the registrants exceeded capacity by 10+% instead of like HPPS exceeded by 40+%.

Well in terms of financial impact, PHPPS will be the ‘cheapest’ and I thought it was a sure thing if we move within 1km going by past years’ record but this year, balloting within 1km. And after visiting the PHPPS thread here, no offence to the school or parents with kids there, I have 2nd thoughts about putting DS there since my Chinese sucks and DH oso not that good. And I dun like the idea that they stream kids into different classes based on capabilities as early as P2.

Haiyah, I oso totally confused. Told DH just put DS in BTPS but DH say no must try, else next time DS may say we bias why DD go RGPS while he go BTPS. Ok, I’m like huh? Oh well, his 2 words ‘must try’, I gotta do all the work.

[BigDevil]

Funz:

As for ACS Primary, well my Dad was an old boys, unfortunately, tak pakay. I was looking at the balloting history of ACS and it seems they have a cut off the last 2 years. Don't understand how this cut off thing works though. Problem is the vacancy for 2C is very low since majority of the space is taken up by alumni and church members.


Can someone explain what that cut off means?

Cut off means that the number of applicants = number of available places in that distance category, so no balloting required. All who fall outside of that distance category will be rejected.

Eg. At 2C, number of places = 50. Number of applicants within 1 km = 22,
number of applicants within 2km = 28, number of applicants outside 2km = 35. This will be a cut off since 22 + 28 = 50. All 35 applicants outside 2km will be rejected.

[verykiasu2010]

Funz:

.....................

And if I balloting within 1km is involved, I think ACS and NYPS will accord higher chances since the last 2 years, the registrants exceeded capacity by 10+% instead of like HPPS exceeded by 40+%.

Well in terms of financial impact, PHPPS will be the 'cheapest' and I thought it was a sure thing if we move within 1km going by past years' record but this year, balloting within 1km. And after visiting the PHPPS thread here, no offence to the school or parents with kids there, I have 2nd thoughts about putting DS there since my Chinese sucks and DH oso not that good. And I dun like the idea that they stream kids into different classes based on capabilities as early as P2.

Haiyah, I oso totally confused. Told DH just put DS in BTPS but DH say no must try, else next time DS may say we bias why DD go RGPS while he go BTPS. Ok, I'm like huh? Oh well, his 2 words 'must try', I gotta do all the work.

NYPS will challenge your chinese lang hor, if you have no intention to outsource chinese coaching / tuition .......

[Funz]

verykiasu2010:

NYPS will challenge your chinese lang hor, if you have no intention to outsource chinese coaching / tuition .......

Yah aware of that. Currently oredi outsourced.

[Funz]

BigDevil:

Cut off means that the number of applicants = number of available places in that distance category, so no balloting required. All who fall outside of that distance category will be rejected.


Eg. At 2C, number of places = 50. Number of applicants within 1 km = 22,
number of applicants within 2km = 28, number of applicants outside 2km = 35. This will be a cut off since 22 + 28 = 50. All 35 applicants outside 2km will be rejected.

Thanks!

[Busymom]

Funz:

Busymom, I did not include HPPS though it was my first choice for PV cos I saw the balloting history, practically every year balloting required for within 1km and highly over subscribed.


Decided to include NYP cos thot if move around that area oso more convenient for DD if DS gets in, since both are nearby.

Hi Funz,

I just checked the balloting history for this year and in the case of HPPS, the balloting under 2C is for > 2km. Not sure why HPPS is quite \"cold\" this year with the 2004 kids' parents, but you can probably try to see next year's trend. By the way, when is your DS due to be registered for P1?

For NYPS, you have to bear in mind the massive Farrier Road project that would soon be launched.

How about through grassroot leader route? You would have more choices of schools in the Holland- Bukit Timah GRC.

[Busymom]

BigDevil:

Cut off means that the number of applicants = number of available places in that distance category, so no balloting required. All who fall outside of that distance category will be rejected.


Eg. At 2C, number of places = 50. Number of applicants within 1 km = 22,
number of applicants within 2km = 28, number of applicants outside 2km = 35. This will be a cut off since 22 + 28 = 50. All 35 applicants outside 2km will be rejected.

Also, just to add, sometimes having a cut off does not necessarily mean that supply = demand for a category. It could be that some parents decided to go to another school instead of going for balloting. I remember noticing in one of the years that ACS initially had to ballot on the day when registration closed, yet somehow, before balloting was to be conducted, it became a case of cut-off. Heard from a friend as well that if there is just 1 more student, sometimes, the school will take in that 1 extra person.

[Funz]

Busymom:

Hi Funz,


I just checked the balloting history for this year and in the case of HPPS, the balloting under 2C is for > 2km. Not sure why HPPS is quite \"cold\" this year with the 2004 kids' parents, but you can probably try to see next year's trend. By the way, when is your DS due to be registered for P1?

For NYPS, you have to bear in mind the massive Farrier Road project that would soon be launched.

How about through grassroot leader route? You would have more choices of schools in the Holland- Bukit Timah GRC.

Gotta register DS next year. Explored a few options so now down to the last option and that is move nearer to the school, which was our 2nd last option. Last option will be to just register him in BTPS.

[Luanee]

Busymom:

Hi Funz,


I just checked the balloting history for this year and in the case of HPPS, the balloting under 2C is for > 2km. Not sure why HPPS is quite \"cold\" this year with the 2004 kids' parents, but you can probably try to see next year's trend. By the way, when is your DS due to be registered for P1?

For NYPS, you have to bear in mind the massive Farrier Road project that would soon be launched.

How about through grassroot leader route? You would have more choices of schools in the Holland- Bukit Timah GRC.

I thot HPPS balloted for 1-2 km this year for 2C ? If you dont like PHPPS, then HPPS may be a good chance as in 2008 everyone within 1km got in without balloting for 2C.

[Busymom]

Luanee:

I thot HPPS balloted for 1-2 km this year for 2C ? If you dont like PHPPS, then HPPS may be a good chance as in 2008 everyone within 1km got in without balloting for 2C.

Initially, I also thought so, but the balloting history found on KSP shows that balloting was required for >2km (green colour) in 2010... or have I interpreted the chart incorrectly?