Chinese electronic dictionary

[cmm]

I’m trying to get a Chinese electronic dictionary for my P3 child. The models available in her school bookshop are a Besta one (comes with warranty) and two Creative ones (no warranty). The latest Creative model comes with input thru stylus.


Would like to get advice frm parents who have experience with these dictionaries which would be better? The bookshop auntie recommends the besta one cos of the warranty (but she also agrees that the creative one is more popular), but my sil’s child used a creative one & highly recommended it.

Personally, I prefer a good old dictionary in the form of a book. But it would be too heavy to carry around in my girl’s already overloaded schoolbag.

Thanx!!!

[ppnqq]

They should be the same because MOE only approved these few models for students to use during examinations so their functions/features almost the same, neither one are given the 'privilege' to have a more enhanced function/feature, else, most would definitely go for the one which will 'benefit' them more. Make sense? JMHO. :roll:


Of course it is always safer to get one with a warranty. Btw, Popular selling them too.

[small]

My child preferred Creative HansVision e-Dictionary, mentioned more user friendly.


Please keep the purchase receipt for the warranty purpose, I think it come with 1 year limited warranty..

[ppnqq]

Ok, had kpo and found out that the latest Creative (cannot cnfm, should be this brand) has more Chinese Idioms than the rest.


So for those who have not gotten the e-dictionary yet may consider this. But must try to see if can get any warranty to be safe.

HTH.

[pixiedust]

We have both Creative and Besta.


Besta is shell case packaging. Maybe more durable ? DS started with Besta and he prefers Besta. Keypad is bigger and there is 笔划 function to show each stroke in big font.

I am left with using the Creative (not the latest version). No shell-case and keypad is small.

I didn’t do a comparision - Vocabulary and 成语 lookup, so far, haven’t found one to be more superior than the other (now at P5).

[Happy Mama]

My DD is in Pri 3 this year and we recently bought Creative PX2101 from school. I think it is one of the approved E-dictionary.

[pixiedust]

This is the MOE approved dictionaries for 2011 PSLE :


http://www.seab.gov.sg/dictionaryList/2011PSLEDictList.pdf

[KittyBin]

Thanks for the link!


Besta models approved by SEAB for use from till 2012/2014 (depending on the model).
Creative models approved by SEAB for use till 2015 (for both PX 2051 & PX2101 models).

The retail price at Popular and school will be the same. The price at Popular (fixed price, no member discount). If the school is organising a sales, then it will be cheaper.
https://www.popular.com.sg/jsp/product/list_product_by_cat.jsp?vca001=35155&vpd005=0&vpd006=9

I am also making a decision to buy one soon.

[KittyBin]

Happy Mama:

My DD is in Pri 3 this year and we recently bought Creative PX2101 from school. I think it is one of the approved E-dictionary.

No need to think so hard leh.

It is definitely approved by SEAB. Otherwise, if they sell the unauthorised model, they will get a lot of feedback, complaints and requests for refunds. Usually, the school will have approved/granted for the sale of those models before the vendors or the school bookstore vendor can go to the school to sell.

[eyktay]

I just got the Besta one cos it has 60000词, think Creative Hansvision is 46000.

Also, feel the buttons to press are bigger. DS prefers Creative cos more friends using that.