Post GE 2011 Discussion

[sharon1234]

To me, either ways, there is no difference to the pocket of the ministers at the end of the day.

[DesertWind]

MummyThreeStreams:

DesertWind:

Hi Hi,

My own wild guess of the new minister's pay should be between SGD500K to SGD800K per annum. Anybody game to poll?

This is what the top civil servants earn. If the ministers' pay is at that level, then all civil servants can also expect a pay cut, coz how can the perm sec earn more than his boss? And if perm sec's pay cut, then the deputy secretary's pay must also be cut. If the deputy secretary's pay is cut, then the director's pay must be cut, etc. etc.

:shock: Yikes! I didn't know that! I just finished reading today's newspapers and was wondering at what the reports were saying about the top civil servants' pay. And PM's remarks about going into politics should not be seen as a \"promotion\" to the civil service etc..

So I was wondering what were they saying about the civil servants' pay? So now I know thanks for your enlightenment! So the top civil servants ALREADY at SGD500 - SGD800K! Yikes! :faint:

Everybody in the govt. service get paid so much what else is there to review? Yes, why should one jump from civil service to minister and get a pay cut? :gloomy:

So bottom-line again, how much should an average minister be paid? With my new-found knowledge, how about SGD1m to SGD1.5m? :faint: (wah piang ooi...)

[daisyt]

Desertwind, how about $4.2million a year for our President? Are u going to faint twice?


http://www.todayonline.com/Singapore/EDC110311-0000251/Parliament-approves-increase-in-Presidents-salary,-expenditure

[MummyThreeStreams]

DesertWind:

So I was wondering what were they saying about the civil servants' pay? So now I know thanks for your enlightenment! So the top civil servants ALREADY at SGD500 - SGD800K! Yikes! :faint:

Everybody in the govt. service get paid so much what else is there to review? Yes, why should one jump from civil service to minister and get a pay cut? :gloomy:

So bottom-line again, how much should an average minister be paid? With my new-found knowledge, how about SGD1m to SGD1.5m? :faint: (wah piang ooi...)

Not everybody in civil service is earning so much lah. Only a handful.

DPM TCH has said civil service pay may need to be reviewed...
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/singaporelocalnews/view/1130707/1/.html I think they will need to be careful with this coz they don't want to lose too many people to the private sector.

I think it's important to settle the principles first, before talking about quantum. It may be that the moral authority for an elected office bearer requires a significant \"discount\" on salaries, but perhaps this may not apply in the same way to the civil service. if so, then it may well be possible for the perm sec to earn more than the political leadership. Imagine how inspiring it would be if the minister can say to his perm sec \" oi, I earn less than you, but I'm working harder!\"
:nunchuk:

But more realistically speaking, while I think a full Minister should earn at least the same as his perm sec (and i'm happy for them to earn more than the perm sec), I think the more junior office bearers (parliamentary secretaries, ministers of state) do not need to earn as much. I.e., The entry-level political salaries can be lower than the higher civil service grades.

[daisyt]

Very interesting. Total 7 parts. Here is part 1, look for the other parts yourself.


新聞挖挖哇：李光耀傳奇 by TaiwanTalks4

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SC-dkoR0KTY&feature=player_embedded

[MummyThreeStreams]

daisyt:

Desertwind, how about $4.2million a year for our President? Are u going to faint twice?


http://www.todayonline.com/Singapore/EDC110311-0000251/Parliament-approves-increase-in-Presidents-salary,-expenditure

Yah, this one I cannot understand. :faint:

[DesertWind]

daisyt:

Desertwind, how about $4.2million a year for our President? Are u going to faint twice?

Surprising after seeing this in today's papers, don't feel like fainting leh....at least it is just one person with SGD4.2m...(dunnoo what sort of logic is that but I don't feel like fainting actually).

But I feel like throwing up after reading about civil service's pay...I think too much for me to handle liow! :sick:

(Perhaps I am regretting should have chosen to join HDB last time when I have the chance instead of joining the private sector big commercial bank, thinking I would be earning more...wah lau I should have gone into the public sector man! )

[SAHM_TAN]

ksi:

Nicole Seah asks for donations online using her own bank account


http://www.asiaone.com/News/AsiaOne%2BNews/Singapore/Story/A1Story20110523-280160.html

Is this another example of her naiveness?
Her new-found fame getting over her head? :?

This was during the election right. Is it stil-ongoing, the request for donation? I thought it stop liao

[Angelight]

Seriously I don't think the President shld be getting this much. What does he actually do other than being head of state and gracing a few events a year? He doesn't have much responsibilities or stress like the ministers, right?

daisyt:

Desertwind, how about $4.2million a year for our President? Are u going to faint twice?

http://www.todayonline.com/Singapore/EDC110311-0000251/Parliament-approves-increase-in-Presidents-salary,-expenditure

[corneyAmber]

SAHM_TAN:

ksi:

Nicole Seah asks for donations online using her own bank account


http://www.asiaone.com/News/AsiaOne%2BNews/Singapore/Story/A1Story20110523-280160.html

Is this another example of her naiveness?
Her new-found fame getting over her head? :?

This was during the election right. Is it stil-ongoing, the request for donation? I thought it stop liao

No..after election, she is soliciting donations via FB for S$35,000 as NSP has overspent for the election compaigning(Tankee, Quality Hotel has billed them...... ). By the way, it is indeed legal for her to ask for donations for the election campaigns even after the elections but I think the mistake is to use a personal bank account in her name(maybe she is really equating NSP as Nicole Seah's Party...) which is not a wise move. The lack of experience in understanding sentiments of people continues to come through...as I said before she needed more years to mature....I look fwd to her future years.