different punishment for similar offence - why?
-
zadrian:
http://andrewlohhp.wordpress.com/2012/06/14/a-slap-on-the-wrist-or-a-slap-on-the-face-of-our-justice-system/I think the punishment was also for their crimes on top of their \"take rap\" charges.
One man was speeding - $150 fine + 6 points.
Other man was for running Illegal Internet Gambling + hurting Police officer.
How was this similar offences ?
Do you think if u were taking a walk then bash up a Neighbourhood Police Post police officer, the TP will fine u and give u demerit points ?
With apologies.....I read from the blog, failed to notice that there were mention of 3 cases, this thread is only about case 1 & 2....
Anyway, as someone pointed out....one was speeding at 95KPH, the other was beating red lights -
Strparent:
Dat's not wat WW said earlier.
reasons explained....... :skeptical:
Please read here, contradiction highlighted.
http://singaporedesk.blogspot.sg/2012/06/minister-and-surgeon.html
越描越黑!
When one receives a police summon for traffic offence in d mail,
isn't it d normal standard procedure for d TP to mail d summons to registered owner of car
to inform him/her of d offence n also for owner to provide details of driver if not himself/herself?
Can someone cfm dis?
Incidentally, d Law Minister's ex has just released a book entitled
\"Authoritarian Rule of Law\".
Brief fr Cambridge University Press (underline mine)-
\"Scholars have generally assumed that authoritarianism and rule of law are mutually incompatible. Convinced that free markets and rule of law must tip authoritarian societies in a liberal direction, nearly all studies of law and contemporary politics have neglected that improbable coupling: authoritarian rule of law. Through a focus on Singapore, this book presents an analysis of authoritarian legalism. It shows how prosperity, public discourse, and a rigorous observance of legal procedure have enabled a reconfigured rule of law such that liberal form encases illiberal content. Institutions and process at the bedrock of rule of law and liberal democracy become tools to constrain dissent while augmenting discretionary political power – even as the national and international legitimacy of the state is secured. This book offers a valuable and original contribution to understanding the complexities of law, language and legitimacy in our time. -
experienced before so can confirm. if one is caught speeding etc and the summons is mailed, it will be sent to the car owner. Car owner then must fill in who is the person behind the wheel at time of offence.
-
Way2GO:
The traffic offences took place in 2005 and 2006 and someone took the rap for him. It was not uncovered only until last year I believe.Angelight:
Unlikely...he was charged in 2006 right? But only sentenced to a fine this year.
IIRC, he was charged last year but only recently sentenced.
d first traffic offence occurred in 2005, second in 2006;
a lapse of six years fr time of first offence committed to being charged in 2011.
d SPF has some explanation to do.
SPF need not explain anything I feel. The judge however, need to explain his sentencing. This is outrageous.
How can two person committing the same offence be sentenced so differently? The judge needs to be sacked for making a mockery out of our judiciary system, which is famed to be fair and just. -
Good article from Choo Zheng Xi of TOC, who listed down all similar cases whereby Sec 182 of the Penal Code has been preferred and all guilty persons sentenced to jail.
Why in this case, Sec 182 PC is not preferred on Woffles but Sec 81(3) of RTA? Is a different charged used so that he can be let off the hook?
http://theonlinecitizen.com/2012/06/questions-remain-in-woffles-wu-matter/ -
hquek:
experienced before so can confirm. if one is caught speeding etc and the summons is mailed, it will be sent to the car owner. Car owner then must fill in who is the person behind the wheel at time of offence.
Thx for d cfm. -
AC_Power:
Gud historical evidence fr TOC article u referred to in support of his argument.
The traffic offences took place in 2005 and 2006 and someone took the rap for him. It was not uncovered only until last year I believe.
SPF need not explain anything I feel. The judge however, need to explain his sentencing. This is outrageous.
How can two person committing the same offence be sentenced so differently? The judge needs to be sacked for making a mockery out of our judiciary system, which is famed to be fair and just.
Those cases will also, in all probability, showed dat a six yrs lapse between time of offence n sentencing is not d norm. I wld say d six yrs lapse is highly unusual.
Dis case wld hv continued to be conveniently buried if someone who knew about it didn't pursue it with d police.
Something smells. d SPF has to explain dis. -
Way2GO:
There isn't a 6 years lapse.
Gud historical evidence fr TOC article u referred to in support of his argument.AC_Power:
The traffic offences took place in 2005 and 2006 and someone took the rap for him. It was not uncovered only until last year I believe.
SPF need not explain anything I feel. The judge however, need to explain his sentencing. This is outrageous.
How can two person committing the same offence be sentenced so differently? The judge needs to be sacked for making a mockery out of our judiciary system, which is famed to be fair and just.
Those cases will also, in all probability, showed dat a six yrs lapse between time of offence n sentencing is not d norm. I wld say d six yrs lapse is highly unusual.
Dis case wld hv continued to be conveniently buried if someone who knew about it didn't pursue it with d police.
Something smells. d SPF has to explain dis.
Okay, let me explain. In 2005 and 2006, our dear Woffles committed the traffic offence. Someone took the rap for him and paid the fines. So, as far as the traffic summons are concern, fine paid up, case close.
Only last year, someone whistle-blew, informing the authority that someone could have took the rap for Woffles for the above traffic offences. That kicked start the investigation. So it is only a year or so for the police to complete the investigation and bring Woffles to court.
It is just unfortunate that his dishonesty is exposed 6 years down the road. How can we blame the police? -
AC_Power:
There isn't a 6 years lapse.
Gud historical evidence fr TOC article u referred to in support of his argument.Way2GO:
[quote=\"AC_Power\"]
The traffic offences took place in 2005 and 2006 and someone took the rap for him. It was not uncovered only until last year I believe.
SPF need not explain anything I feel. The judge however, need to explain his sentencing. This is outrageous.
How can two person committing the same offence be sentenced so differently? The judge needs to be sacked for making a mockery out of our judiciary system, which is famed to be fair and just.
Those cases will also, in all probability, showed dat a six yrs lapse between time of offence n sentencing is not d norm. I wld say d six yrs lapse is highly unusual.
Dis case wld hv continued to be conveniently buried if someone who knew about it didn't pursue it with d police.
Something smells. d SPF has to explain dis.
Okay, let me explain. In 2005 and 2006, our dear Woffles committed the traffic offence. Someone took the rap for him and paid the fines. So, as far as the traffic summons are concern, fine paid up, case close.
Only last year, someone whistle-blew, informing the authority that someone could have took the rap for Woffles for the above traffic offences. That kicked start the investigation. So it is only a year or so for the police to complete the investigation and bring Woffles to court.
It is just unfortunate that his dishonesty is exposed 6 years down the road. How can we blame the police?[/quote]blame the whistle-blower, so late then blow :evil: :evil: -
verykiasu2010:
Hahaha....
blame the whistle-blower, so late then blow :evil: :evil:
But since he is a plastic surgeon, certainly he can cover up better. So take longer time for people to discover.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login17
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects