[Novena] Primary Schools
-
P1 mummy:
Your pt 3. Assuming someone has a few properties. All are pretty close to one another. However, only 1 is near to a good school and the family doesn't stay there. Instead, that place is a storage hub for the family. Is this consider a cheat? If you are in the same shoe owning a few properties, I believe you will also use the address that is nearest to a good school.Just to clarify for those who are getting lost among the trees. Very simple. I have no issue with genuine residents in the area competing for a place in whichever school they try to get their kids into. I have no god given right - but I do have more of a right (legally) than some. In summary:
1. Own and live in a property less than 1km for many years - no issue
2. Recently bought or rented a property less than 1km AND actually live there - no issue
3. Bought or rented a place for P1 registration BUT still living elsewhere within Singapore - illegal and considered cheating
4. Using a parents/relatives/friends address for P1 registration without filling out a statutory declaration as you will only be considered as a 1-2km applicant - illegal and considered cheating.
I shall pursue those in categories 3 & 4 as cheats. It will take a few weeks and will almost definitely occur after balloting - but they will get caught eventually. No doubt. Question rightly or wrongly that how is is this possible. But don't be so naive to think it's okay to cheat and get away with it.
Why do people have a problem in outing those who clearly cheat. This is part of the problem as to why foreigners prosper over us singaporeans - they act decisively when needed. When we do it - people pray for our downfall. Wake up!
My words may be strong but my actions are far stronger! -
magic8ball:
becknat68:
updates as at 11am :
SCGS : 29 seats, 46 SC within 1KM
RGPS : 42 seats, 48 SC , 37 within 1KM, 2 1-2KM, 9 outside 2KM
SMPS : 101 seats, 87 SCs, no breakdown of distance available
SMPS: 87 SCs, of which 43 outside 2km.
Let's look at the bigger picture. We just want our girls to get into school. At this rate, the will be more disappointed families if people don't withdraw from scgs and switch to smps. If things stay status quo, there will be 17 disappointments (46-29). If parents realize this, some should actually switch to smps so the number of disappointments are minimized. 14 seats left at smps, if 15 switch to smps, it would force a ballot at smps for those outside of 2km, chances would be 101-(87-43)=57 spaces for of 58 (43+15) applicants. for scgs, it would be 29 of 31. Disappontments -maximum 3, and possibly only two as all who switch could get seats.
But as it stands, 17 will definitely be disappointed at scgs.
Look at the big picture.
good analysis, but I think those who like to take risk is not at all an issue sine for every 3 child 2 will be getting in (3:2) the ratio is quite fine -
Saki:
magic8ball:
[quote=\"becknat68\"]updates as at 11am :
SCGS : 29 seats, 46 SC within 1KM
RGPS : 42 seats, 48 SC , 37 within 1KM, 2 1-2KM, 9 outside 2KM
SMPS : 101 seats, 87 SCs, no breakdown of distance available
SMPS: 87 SCs, of which 43 outside 2km.
Let's look at the bigger picture. We just want our girls to get into school. At this rate, the will be more disappointed families if people don't withdraw from scgs and switch to smps. If things stay status quo, there will be 17 disappointments (46-29). If parents realize this, some should actually switch to smps so the number of disappointments are minimized. 14 seats left at smps, if 15 switch to smps, it would force a ballot at smps for those outside of 2km, chances would be 101-(87-43)=57 spaces for of 58 (43+15) applicants. for scgs, it would be 29 of 31. Disappontments -maximum 3, and possibly only two as all who switch could get seats.
But as it stands, 17 will definitely be disappointed at scgs.
Look at the big picture.
good analysis, but I think those who like to take risk is not at all an issue sine for every 3 child 2 will be getting in (3:2) the ratio is quite fine[/quote]But what happens to those who are disappointed? Bhps? The downside can be quite large and overall would be worse off. that's the economics speaking. -
Scary:
Your pt 3, there is nothing the government can do. They can purchase the property, stayed there till the registration is over, then move out or vacant it or rent out. At the point of registration, it is consider legal and there is nothing you can do. You have no case against them.
Your pt 3. Assuming someone has a few properties. All are pretty close to one another. However, only 1 is near to a good school and the family doesn't stay there. Instead, that place is a storage hub for the family. Is this consider a cheat? If you are in the same shoe owning a few properties, I believe you will also use the address that is nearest to a good school.P1 mummy:
Just to clarify for those who are getting lost among the trees. Very simple. I have no issue with genuine residents in the area competing for a place in whichever school they try to get their kids into. I have no god given right - but I do have more of a right (legally) than some. In summary:
1. Own and live in a property less than 1km for many years - no issue
2. Recently bought or rented a property less than 1km AND actually live there - no issue
3. Bought or rented a place for P1 registration BUT still living elsewhere within Singapore - illegal and considered cheating
4. Using a parents/relatives/friends address for P1 registration without filling out a statutory declaration as you will only be considered as a 1-2km applicant - illegal and considered cheating.
I shall pursue those in categories 3 & 4 as cheats. It will take a few weeks and will almost definitely occur after balloting - but they will get caught eventually. No doubt. Question rightly or wrongly that how is is this possible. But don't be so naive to think it's okay to cheat and get away with it.
Why do people have a problem in outing those who clearly cheat. This is part of the problem as to why foreigners prosper over us singaporeans - they act decisively when needed. When we do it - people pray for our downfall. Wake up!
My words may be strong but my actions are far stronger!
Your pt 4, again there is nothing the government can do. Nowaday, the property is so high, how you expect the young family to own a property. They have no choice but to stay with their parents/friends/relative. You have no legal stand against them.
All your points are not classified cheating. If you do not has the permission to use the address, it is consider cheating.
You are just wasting $$ engaging lawyer to fight an impossible battle.
I would suggest, find way to join the school committee. Get in by phase 2A. Don't just complain here. -
Saki… 17 still don’t get in. That doesn’t change.
-
happydaddy:
Your pt 3, there is nothing the government can do. They can purchase the property, stayed there till the registration is over, then move out or vacant it or rent out. At the point of registration, it is consider legal and there is nothing you can do. You have no case against them.
Your pt 3. Assuming someone has a few properties. All are pretty close to one another. However, only 1 is near to a good school and the family doesn't stay there. Instead, that place is a storage hub for the family. Is this consider a cheat? If you are in the same shoe owning a few properties, I believe you will also use the address that is nearest to a good school.Scary:
[quote=\"P1 mummy\"]Just to clarify for those who are getting lost among the trees. Very simple. I have no issue with genuine residents in the area competing for a place in whichever school they try to get their kids into. I have no god given right - but I do have more of a right (legally) than some. In summary:
1. Own and live in a property less than 1km for many years - no issue
2. Recently bought or rented a property less than 1km AND actually live there - no issue
3. Bought or rented a place for P1 registration BUT still living elsewhere within Singapore - illegal and considered cheating
4. Using a parents/relatives/friends address for P1 registration without filling out a statutory declaration as you will only be considered as a 1-2km applicant - illegal and considered cheating.
I shall pursue those in categories 3 & 4 as cheats. It will take a few weeks and will almost definitely occur after balloting - but they will get caught eventually. No doubt. Question rightly or wrongly that how is is this possible. But don't be so naive to think it's okay to cheat and get away with it.
Why do people have a problem in outing those who clearly cheat. This is part of the problem as to why foreigners prosper over us singaporeans - they act decisively when needed. When we do it - people pray for our downfall. Wake up!
My words may be strong but my actions are far stronger!
Your pt 4, again there is nothing the government can do. Nowaday, the property is so high, how you expect the young family to own a property. They have no choice but to stay with their parents/friends/relative. You have no legal stand against them.
All your points are not classified cheating. If you do not has the permission to use the address, it is consider cheating.
You are just wasting $$ engaging lawyer to fight an impossible battle.
Lol happydaddy you are very transparent.
I would suggest, find way to join the school committee. Get in by phase 2A. Don't just complain here.[/quote] -
Happy daddy… You are very transparent…
Be careful p1 mummy may now zoom in on you! -
Happy daddy… You are very transparent…
Be careful p1 mummy may now zoom in on you! -
Happy daddy… You are very transparent…
Be careful p1 mummy may now zoom in on you! -
Happy daddy… You are very transparent…
Be careful p1 mummy may now zoom in on you!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login