Q&A - P3 Science
-
Anyone has idea about the movement of cockroach, hopping , flying or both?
Paul put some animals into 3 groups, X,Y,and Z, as shown in the table below
Group X: grasshopper, sparrow
Group Y: Bee, Bat
Group Z:Shhark, Turtle
In which group would you put the word "cockroach"?
Thanks! -
super-duper-quadruple:
I've posted the reply on your thread.Anyone has idea about the movement of cockroach, hopping , flying or both?
Paul put some animals into 3 groups, X,Y,and Z, as shown in the table below
Group X: grasshopper, sparrow
Group Y: Bee, Bat
Group Z:Shhark, Turtle
In which group would you put the word \"cockroach\"?
Thanks!
Group X -
why is grain a living thing?
-
24hr-mum:
why is grain a living thing?
Hi 24hr-mum
Actually I dare not re-visit this issue because it was extensively discussed 2 years ago. Anyway since nobody is coming forward, let me try to summaries what have been discussed.
Firstly we need to define the \"Characteristics of living thing\" :
1. Can move (no need to move freely from place to place)
2. Can reproduction
3. Can die
4. Can growth
5. Respond to stimulus
6. Carryout gaseous exchange
7. Made of cells
8. Need energy
9. Produces waste
Unfortunately, there is no guidelines on how many criteria must be met before an object is considered as a living thing although in Pr sch I think criteria 2,3 & 4 are considered essential.
A grain meets most of the criteria (except 1, 5) which in my opinion is a living thing.
In the past discussion, we were questioning whether is a cut leaf a living thing..... conclusion I don't know.
Cheers -
thanks. my girl’s sch sci teacher say its a livg thing but didnt explain much. someone else said grain such as green bean is a living thing cos when u give it water and warmth it can sprout and grow…
-
the sch sci teacher just ask me go n google abt why grain is living. sigh. u see lah!
-
24hr-mum:
the sch sci teacher just ask me go n google abt why grain is living. sigh. u see lah!
24hr-mum,
My child said that his science teacher also asked the class to go and google for some of the questions that were asked in class that were not in the textbook. Seems like the norm nowadays. -
plum-cake:
I've posted the reply on your thread.super-duper-quadruple:
Anyone has idea about the movement of cockroach, hopping , flying or both?
Thanks!
Group X
Thanks -
atutor2001:
Hi,24hr-mum:
why is grain a living thing?
Hi 24hr-mum
Actually I dare not re-visit this issue because it was extensively discussed 2 years ago. Anyway since nobody is coming forward, let me try to summaries what have been discussed.
Firstly we need to define the \"Characteristics of living thing\" :
1. Can move (no need to move freely from place to place)
2. Can reproduction
3. Can die
4. Can growth
5. Respond to stimulus
6. Carryout gaseous exchange
7. Made of cells
8. Need energy
9. Produces waste
Unfortunately, there is no guidelines on how many criteria must be met before an object is considered as a living thing although in Pr sch I think criteria 2,3 & 4 are considered essential.
A grain meets most of the criteria (except 1, 5) which in my opinion is a living thing.
In the past discussion, we were questioning whether is a cut leaf a living thing..... conclusion I don't know.
Cheers
May I ask, if 'rubber' is consider as a 'non-living thing' that is once alive? If yes, then 'sap' of a tree is consider alive on its own? Is an orange consider as a living thing? -
teh_oh:
Hi teh oh
Hi,
May I ask, if 'rubber' is consider as a 'non-living thing' that is once alive? If yes, then 'sap' of a tree is consider alive on its own? Is an orange consider as a living thing?
Firstly, I would consider 'rubber' as a 'non-living thing' that was from things that are once alive and not \"rubber was once alive\"
Imo, 'sap' should be classified as not alive even when it is in a live tree because 'sap' is only part of the cells (if I am not wrong). I asked myself is blood alive and my answer is no. So I apply the same logic. Another example is, \"Is silk once alive?\" My answer is no but silk is from things that were once alive.
Honestly I really don't know the answer as the definition of alive is not specific. However, I think the real problem is that over the years, some questions have been wrongly phrased, omitting the words \"from things\" and the questions being shortened to \"rubber is once alive\". It should be \"rubber is from things that are once alive.\"
Just my opinion.
Regards
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login4
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects