River Valley High School [*IP]
-
Edureach:
Edureach,WeiHan
Got your point. The introduction of a constrasting subject has disenabled the opportunity for top science students to pursue triple science.
Is a trade-off.
The point is that RV's present change has ruled out completely the chance to do triple sciences while before the change, a better student who wish may consider the following combination, for example, h2 bio, h2 phys, h2 chem, h2 maths, h1 econs, GP, PW and higher MTL. And it still satisfy the new A level requirement. -
WeiHan:
Edureach,Edureach:
WeiHan
Got your point. The introduction of a constrasting subject has disenabled the opportunity for top science students to pursue triple science.
Is a trade-off.
The point is that RV's present change has ruled out completely the chance to do triple sciences while before the change, a better student who wish may consider the following combination, for example, h2 bio, h2 phys, h2 chem, h2 maths, h1 econs, GP, PW and higher MTL. And it still satisfy the new A level requirement.
Wah! 12 academic units excluding H3. Nowadays, this combi is rarely found even in RI and HCI. Schools have to seek permission from MOE and is rarely granted.
Probably RVH has considered the general interest of its cohort rather than special circumstances. -
WeiHan:
majority of RV students are in fact taking 4H2 with some taking additional H3 and a few 2 H3. dont think RV has change subject combi.
But the \"norm\" in most top schools have always been doing at least 4H2. It shows that my understanding is correct now. The contrasting humanities can be a H1. In this case, there is no rationale for RV to change the subject combination formatt as there were already prior batches who has done well with triple sciences. I am starting to think that it is a bad change from the part of RV. Parents better go and feedback. Do you want to force Rv's students to be \"norm\"?
any RV year 5/6 parents has the subject combi to share? -
Edureach:
Surely HCI and RI offer such combination, otherwise, how do the schools produce so many students with 8 distinctions or even 9 distinctions.
Wah! 12 academic units excluding H3. Nowadays, this combi is rarely found even in RI and HCI. Schools have to seek permission from MOE and is rarely granted.
Probably RVH has considered the general interest of its cohort rather than special circumstances. -
Hello everyone I’m new here. Hope y’all don’t mind I’m not a parent but a student from the class of 2010.
Just to add to the current discussion, I know for a fact that some of my friends took H2 triple science and mathematics as well has H1 economics as a contrasting subject.
Personally I feel that the advantages of taking that combination do not justify the price paid. For example, the workload is extremely heavy - other than the fact that biology isn’t easy on the brain, H1 econs is just as rigorous (in terms of essay writing and analytical skills) as H2 econs, and the content is around 75% of the full syllabus (everything except market structure). This is especially so because typical hardcore science students have problems in acquiring skills for this subject.
Thus the advice I would give juniors is to choose either Physics or Biology, and spend the time saved on science attachment programmes offerred the NUS, NTU, ASTAR, DSTA etc. This will add a new dimension to the student profile, because it shows that the student is not just capable of rote learning, but is also equipped with the immense body of skills needed for research.
Therefore, I feel that the principal’s decision is not detrimental to students in the ways mentioned above.
Personally, I approve of his decision because RV students are generally too skewed towards science to the extent that many struggle in GP and Econs when they reach JC level. -
xznat:
Why are many RV's students skewed towards science? I thought it is because the school has rigorous programs in science and maths which is a good thing. Can the school equally say that it has plan to invigorate its humanities program such that it attracts student interest in these subjects? I think it is nice to be balanced but can the school say that it will have a rigorous humanities program too?Hello everyone I'm new here. Hope y'all don't mind I'm not a parent but a student from the class of 2010.
Just to add to the current discussion, I know for a fact that some of my friends took H2 triple science and mathematics as well has H1 economics as a contrasting subject.
Personally I feel that the advantages of taking that combination do not justify the price paid. For example, the workload is extremely heavy - other than the fact that biology isn't easy on the brain, H1 econs is just as rigorous (in terms of essay writing and analytical skills) as H2 econs, and the content is around 75% of the full syllabus (everything except market structure). This is especially so because typical hardcore science students have problems in acquiring skills for this subject.
Thus the advice I would give juniors is to choose either Physics or Biology, and spend the time saved on science attachment programmes offerred the NUS, NTU, ASTAR, DSTA etc. This will add a new dimension to the student profile, because it shows that the student is not just capable of rote learning, but is also equipped with the immense body of skills needed for research.
Therefore, I feel that the principal's decision is not detrimental to students in the ways mentioned above.
Personally, I approve of his decision because RV students are generally too skewed towards science to the extent that many struggle in GP and Econs when they reach JC level. -
It is a good thing no doubt but there are more opportunities for external exposure for science than for arts, at least when RV is concerned.
For example, humanities students can attend:
Pre U seminar
All the MUNs (SMUN, RMUN, THIMUN)
Law attachment programme
NTU attachment
in contrast, for science students:
ASTAR and DSTA secondary/JC scholarships
NUS, NTU attachment programmes, which culminate in SSEF
ASTAR and DSTA attachment programmes
Overseas Science Attachment Programme (to countries like Canada, USA etc.)
International Science Youth Forum
National Science Challenge
All the Olympiads
The nature of events available (not just the number) are rather different - with the exception of THIMUN, programmes available to science students are lower in profile and even prestige.
The major caveat is that this might be a national trend instead of a schoolwide one, but as someone who has been to events from both groups, I can vouch with my limited experience that the school prepared science students better. I personally had a lot of attention from the teacher ic while preparing for NSC, ISYF, OSAP and DSTA scholarship interviews while there was almost no training for SMUN. In fact, in my time only those who went for Pre-U sem and THIMUN had sufficient training.
Another notable fact is that MOE does not offer the Humanities Scholarship to RV students, thus depriving students of a so-called (ahem sorry for the use of this word but unlike someone else it is used appropriately here) "humanities-exclusive" scholarship.
Of course, as someone from the science stream, I might have a skewed view. If anyone can point out that the humanities students do receive equal opportunities, I would stand gladly corrected.
So back to the point, I believe that a possible result of Mr Koh’s decision would be that RVians start to stop seeing triple science as a holy grail of year two streaming, and to consider the fact that the pursuit of the arts and the humanities is another viable choice (regardless of what were his intentions in the first place). In my year, some students were enraptured the idea of TRIPLE SCIENCE and took it for the prestige, therefore disregarding the other stream. They ended up taking all arts/humanities subjects in the ‘A’ level, excluding Mathematics. This could be a disadvantage because at that level, the humanities are highly skills-intensive.
Does anyone have an alternative viewpoint to share? -
I do agree triple sciences is not the holy status, it really depend on your interest and goals. Bicultural scholarship from MOE belongs to humanities scholarship and it is available in RV too. This year, the school has great achievement in attracting the highest record of year 3 students to take up bicultural. I do see cases in RV where opportunities are given to non elite / top scorers. They do look into the other sides and qualities in you beside academic results. I have heard from a student from one of the elite school that if you are not academic good, very unlikely you have opportunity in some areas. And i know, one of the areas RV stress a lot in is 学思。
-
daisyt:
I do agree triple sciences is not the holy status, it really depend on your interest and goals.
Perhaps the main beef I had is that many students in Years 1 and 2 are not exposed to the arts/humanities sufficiently enough to \"discover\" their interest, if any. The programmes I posted above are for those Years 3 and above. In contrast, some Sciences attachment programmes are avaialbe to those as young as Year 2, which was when I did my first attachment. Put this on top of the fact that there is some sort of a majestic aura around the \"triple science\", and you have a problem in which many of those with undiscovered flair for the arts/humanities make the wrong choice.
However to some extent this is an inenvitable problem as writing style and personal voice (both which are very important to the two areas) usually develop quite late. -
xznat:
That was what I meant when I said whether the school has a program to \"attracts student interest\", I have in mind as early as sec1 nd 2. However, a more careful thought shows that it is probably too early as \"interesting\" humanities most likely is related with higher writing skills and on top of that expository in nature which requires maturity. Sec3 and 4 is about the right time. Besides, do we have a pure humanities program as early as sec 3 and sec 4? My suggestion is that the school should focus more in building language and writing skills for sec 1 and sec 2 students. Language and writing ability should come in handy for those wishing to take up humnaities later.daisyt:
I do agree triple sciences is not the holy status, it really depend on your interest and goals.
Perhaps the main beef I had is that many students in Years 1 and 2 are not exposed to the arts/humanities sufficiently enough to \"discover\" their interest, if any. The programmes I posted above are for those Years 3 and above. In contrast, some Sciences attachment programmes are avaialbe to those as young as Year 2, which was when I did my first attachment. Put this on top of the fact that there is some sort of a majestic aura around the \"triple science\", and you have a problem in which many of those with undiscovered flair for the arts/humanities make the wrong choice.
However to some extent this is an inenvitable problem as writing style and personal voice (both which are very important to the two areas) usually develop quite late.
Regarding your point about trend towards humanities, it is true since i have read somewhere in Tharman's speech (when he was MOE minister) that they wish student to develop thinking skills that enable them to tackle problems that do not have a clear-cut black and white answers.
My view is actually more liberal. I think that whatever subjects or courses the students take during their formation years, the curriculum must develop his critical thinking, analytic and writing skills (you know all the basic stuffs). The good foundation will then enable him/her to switch to whichever areas of his/her interest. Even a professional (in any profession) needs constant unlearning and relearning. The mindset and thinking skill will always be useful.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login4
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects