Review of Secondary/IP Schools
-
phankao:
Yes, this neighbour said so too.Jennifer:
An acquaintence's boy's PSLE score was ard 240+, did not qualify for the Hwa Chong/ NUSH/ ACS(I), she chose Catholic High instead of SJI even though distance wise SJI is nearer. She says the sch is ok and her boy is happy. She did not like Nan Hua (I forgot the reason why).
I heard SJI coming up with their own 6 yr IP prog. Anyone heard? -
phankao:
That's interesting. Wonder if it'll be an all-boys IP or if they'll join hands with CJC.Jennifer:
An acquaintence's boy's PSLE score was ard 240+, did not qualify for the Hwa Chong/ NUSH/ ACS(I), she chose Catholic High instead of SJI even though distance wise SJI is nearer. She says the sch is ok and her boy is happy. She did not like Nan Hua (I forgot the reason why).
I heard SJI coming up with their own 6 yr IP prog. Anyone heard? -
turquoise:
Hi, saw turquoise's post in another topic that I wish to add on. However I feel that it is more relevant to post in this topic, hence I copy turquoise's last post into here. Hope this is fine for all and turquoise won't mind me doing that.
I agree. The training the GEP kids receive in their project & daily work makes them independent learners and more suited for the IP route. This is what the IP schools look out for during their DSA selection process. It is not just results, but aptitude and attitude.
I was at the Open House of one of Singapore's premier schools (not IP). The Principal said that you should choose IP schools only if you are a GEP student or someone who's an independent learner and capable of doing project work. Otherwise, the IP route is not for you.
Last year, when my girl was choosing Sec School, IP was really something new and a mystery to us. After asking around for opinions from friends of teachers and parents, I received different comments, mostly negative comments. To me, and maybe a few of us, IP means no \"O\" level and full stop. A friend of mine who was a teacher gave me the same comments as what Turquoise had mentioned \"someone who's an independent learner and capable of doing project work\". In fact, his comments consist a bit more, \"suitable for kids who are outspoken and open.\" Another friend of mine, her daughter in IP, told me her daughter was very stressed and could not cope up with the work. She was trying to find tuition teacher but being IP, it was difficult and expensive. Her advice to me was \"If you don't want your child to feel stress, better don't get into IP\".
Now, as my girl steps into IP Sec 1, I conclude, its not so simple as no \"O\" level and stressful. How I wish, this kind of teaching can be applied to more Primary Schools. My girl is enjoying a lot in this type of environment. A lot of research, project work, presentation, thinking skill and expressing of their views. They are \"forced\" to think and work with different types of classmates with different characters and level of tolerance. Human relationship is always not easy to handle but I am quite glad that she is being widely exposed now.
In many subjects and even her CCA, they receive basic training and off you go with your team to tackle the projects.
I personally feel that when judging if our kids are suitable for IP, GEP or non GEP is not really an issue. Its more on the learning attitute, adaptation and character. A friend of mine even misunderstood that my girl was formaly GEP being because she is in IP now.
I hope this post can be of much help to those parents who are considering IP but not very sure what IP is or has a misconcept about IP, like me last year
-
phankao:
I heard that for DSA - my friend's son was interviewed at HCI in Chinese! And he wasn't very comfortable with that. Did that happen to any of your boys?
The interview was bilingual. According to my son (he went through the interview last year), there were a panel of 3 interviewers interviewing 3 P6 students at the same time. Any of the interviewers can ask questions (one of them would ask in Mandarin), and any of the 3 students can choose to answer first. If you choose not to voice your view, also fine. -
lizawa:
The interview was bilingual. According to my son (he went through the interview last year), there were a panel of 3 interviewers interviewing 3 P6 students at the same time. Any of the interviewers can ask questions (one of them would ask in Mandarin), and any of the 3 students can choose to answer first. If you choose not to voice your view, also fine.
Heard there might be 2nd interview. Is that true and common? and which school normally conduct 2nd interview? -
daisyt:
Hi daisyt,Hi, saw turquoise's post in another topic that I wish to add on. However I feel that it is more relevant to post in this topic, hence I copy turquoise's last post into here. Hope this is fine for all and turquoise won't mind me doing that.
Last year, when my girl was choosing Sec School, IP was really something new and a mystery to us. After asking around for opinions from friends of teachers and parents, I received different comments, mostly negative comments. To me, and maybe a few of us, IP means no \"O\" level and full stop. A friend of mine who was a teacher gave me the same comments as what Turquoise had mentioned \"someone who's an independent learner and capable of doing project work\". In fact, his comments consist a bit more, \"suitable for kids who are outspoken and open.\" Another friend of mine, her daughter in IP, told me her daughter was very stressed and could not cope up with the work. She was trying to find tuition teacher but being IP, it was difficult and expensive. Her advice to me was \"If you don't want your child to feel stress, better don't get into IP\".
Now, as my girl steps into IP Sec 1, I conclude, its not so simple as no \"O\" level and stressful. How I wish, this kind of teaching can be applied to more Primary Schools. My girl is enjoying a lot in this type of environment. A lot of research, project work, presentation, thinking skill and expressing of their views. They are \"forced\" to think and work with different types of classmates with different characters and level of tolerance. Human relationship is always not easy to handle but I am quite glad that she is being widely exposed now.
In many subjects and even her CCA, they receive basic training and off you go with your team to tackle the projects.
I personally feel that when judging if our kids are suitable for IP, GEP or non GEP is not really an issue. Its more on the learning attitute, adaptation and character. A friend of mine even misunderstood that my girl was formaly GEP being because she is in IP now.
I hope this post can be of much help to those parents who are considering IP but not very sure what IP is or has a misconcept about IP, like me last year
Thanks for sharing with us your daughter's experience. It's much appreciated. Is your daughter in RGS? -
turquoise:
No lah, she in RVHS.
Hi daisyt,
Thanks for sharing with us your daughter's experience. It's much appreciated. Is your daughter in RGS? -
I’m curious to know if non-SAP/IP sch admits students via DSA ? I’m talking abt schs with standards below HCI, RI, RGS, RV, etc, but above the average neighbourhood sch. Eg , catholic high, SJI, crescent girls, even bukit panjang high govt. Seems to me nobody apply DSA to these schools. Is it they don’t have DSA excercise or nobody interested ?
-
joconde:
I'm curious to know if non-SAP/IP sch admits students via DSA ? I'm talking abt schs with standards below HCI, RI, RGS, RV, etc, but above the average neighbourhood sch. Eg , catholic high, SJI, crescent girls, even bukit panjang high govt. Seems to me nobody apply DSA to these schools. Is it they don't have DSA excercise or nobody interested ?
Oh yes there are, I know of two cases DSA for Anderson Sec. -
joconde:
I'm curious to know if non-SAP/IP sch admits students via DSA ? I'm talking abt schs with standards below HCI, RI, RGS, RV, etc, but above the average neighbourhood sch. Eg , catholic high, SJI, crescent girls, even bukit panjang high govt. Seems to me nobody apply DSA to these schools. Is it they don't have DSA excercise or nobody interested ?
Yes, there are. If you check the MOE website there's a long list of schools that take in DSA applications. A lot of them are for niche sports/aesthetics etc.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login7
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects