All About CCTV/spy camera for monitoring maids

[jtoh]

omgmum:

I have 5 wireless webcams: living room, baby's room, dining room and kitchen. I kinda regret going wireless because the webcams really slow down my internet connection, even after installing powerlines. If you want to install, go for wired, unless you absolutely don't want to pull cables.


I must admit that I'm paranoid but mine is a low-floor unit without grilles, so it's also for security as well.

Nowadays, most webcams and cctvs allow you to view footage over the internet, and you can get a separate recorder for both.

Advantages of webcams:
- more attractive than cctv, especially if wireless
- better resolution than cctv
- can be easier to install if you're IT savvy.
- some have privacy modes, and you can turn off the cams via internet or smartphones.

Disadvantages of webcams:
- slow down the internet connection (for wireless)
- most have no Infra-red capabilities, which means that they get quite useless nearing the late afternoons or early evenings.

Advantages of cctv:
- cheaper than webcams
- IR cctv are much cheaper than IR webcams which cost at least 1k and above. (infra red is necessary if you suspect your maid is sneaking out at night when you're all asleep.)
- wireless cctv are very unstable and unsecured and are not common

Disadvantage of cctv:
- ugly cabling.

I wish that I had installed CCTVs instead, but I chose webcams because I can't have the cabling done. CCTVs are more useful for monitoring and recording, while webcams (even the pan tilt zoom ones) are most useful for live monitoring. Cos you can't really make use of all the functions when you're recording. I have pan tilt zoom ones, and I can tell you that you don't really need the zoom function, and even if you use them, you'll find that the resolution may not be that good!

Another piece of advice the installer told me (after I'd bought the webcams!), was that it's better to have more basic cameras or CCTV to capture the biggest possible area of the house, than to have a few expensive webcams (Pan tilt zoom) that covers only a small area of the house.

It'll be good if you go for uninterrupted power supply cos that way, the cams or cctvs will be connected to the main power supply and there's no way for anyone to switch them off. I've actually heard horror stories of smart maids turning off the surveillance cameras! :shock:

Thanks omgmum.

[omgmum]

nms1:

I would disagree. If I had a camera pointing at me all day while I was working I would feel very uncomfortable even if I wasn't doing anything wrong.

I understand that if you don't have anyone around to supervise the maid, you may feel it is necessary but you also need to put yourself in the maid's shoes.

I agree that it's really uncomfortable and I have to keep reminding myself not to do things like scratch myself and shake my legs! :rotflmao:

But after some time, I got used to it. My rationale is that I will never, ever compromise the privacy of the maid. I do it, so that she and I can have peace of mind. If she's innocent, there's video to prove it. If we do anything wrong to her, there's also proof. It's actually there to protect all innocent parties.

Businesses have them, retail outlets and banks have them. But we still go to work and still shop and bank right? My maid, especially when she's new, is ultimately a stranger. The security and safety of my home is as important to me as their security and safety are for businesses and shops.

And anyway, maids are very smart. Some will stand in front of the cameras and wave to show that they are working. Some will hide beyond the coverage of the cameras.

[zhizunbao]

Thanks expert omgmum!

[alishong]

Hi, would like to share that i just installed the wired cctv last sat cos i could not cope with the wireless configuration


I should say the quality is so good that i regret i din install earlier. Not only monitor maid but also make sure my son is doing his homework.

Btw i have a month old Dlink 930 wireless IPcam to let go if anyone interested. Only used for 1 week to test and give up after that.

Have to say that it was very easy to install but the configuration part was
a nightmare.

[phtthp]

where did you buy yr spy clock ? what brand, how much ?

[tamarind]

Please note that MOM has asked employers to remove CCTVs from maids' room. Check out my blog :


http://singaporemaid.blogspot.com/2011/09/employers-asked-to-remove-cctvs-from.html

[LOLMum]

i agree it is a tad too much to install cctv in the maid’s room and toilet (if any).

[Funz]

What were these employers thinking in the first place. Installing CCTV in the rooms of the maids.

[phtthp]

installing CCTVs in maid's room and in toilets is wrong... it becomes infringement & Violation into personal privacy, violation of human rights! .


toilet is where ... people strip naked, bathe, wash private parts, undress, change underwear, change panty, bra, pee, pass motion.

maid's room is where ... she undress herself, change into a new set of clean clothing.

leading to dangerous consequences ...
imagine if the maid's boss is a man, or if there are any male occupants living inside the house (eg: can be your husband, your son, father, father in law, uncle, etc).

if any male occupant staying inside your house happen to lay hands on CCTV, happen to play back the video contents, then hide inside his bedroom secretly continue to watch how the maid strips naked, how the maid bathe, it becomes like .... watching an RA movie sneakily. This is dangerous!

Unknowingly, you are turning your home into a potential scene of crime one day - for any male occupant staying inside your home to rape your maid ( including enticing your own husband, your son, etc), esp when the house is alone one day, except for 2 of them.

[nms1]

tamarind:

Please note that MOM has asked employers to remove CCTVs from maids' room. Check out my blog :


http://singaporemaid.blogspot.com/2011/09/employers-asked-to-remove-cctvs-from.html

I can't believe that people even think this is OK - how would they like it if there was a camera in their bedroom?!