Q&A - P3 Science
-
tianzhu:
Hi Tianzhu,Hi Dharma
I am thinking along this line, basing on the observation of the diagrams in this question.
The same amount of brown gas can be stored in the jar as shown in the first diagram.
The second diagram shows that the brown gas can be expanded to take a bigger volumes (jar and flask)
As seen from the first diagram, the brown gas is occupying a smaller volume as compared to the second picture. Therefore, it’s compressed, otherwise,how can it take up a smaller space.
Best wishes
I looked it this way …
The jar was filled w/ brown gas and covered w/ a cardboard. They a flask is inverted and placed on the cardboard. The brown gas will fill the whole space in both jar and flask.
At first when the cardboard was placed on the jar, the brown gas was contained in the jar and it took up the shape and volume of the jar. When the cardboard was removed the brown gas now spread to take the shape and volume of the jar and flask.
The fact that the brown gas spread to fill up both jar and flask does not mean that it was compressed at first before the cardboard was removed. -
Hi Dharma
Perhaps, we add some figures for illustration purposes.
Consider the jar and flask to be of similar capacities, let’s say 500ml.
At first, the brown gas was stored in the 500ml jar.
After the cardboard was removed, it expanded to occupy a volume of 1000ml.
How do we explain the fact that the brown gas was able to be stored in the 500ml jar as in the first picture?The logical explanation is it can be compressed to occupy a smaller space.
Best wishes -
tianzhu:
Tianzhu,Hi Dharma
Perhaps, we add some figures for illustration purposes.
Consider the jar and flask to be of similar capacities, let’s say 500ml.
At first, the brown gas was stored in the 500ml jar.
After the cardboard was removed, it expanded to occupy a volume of 1000ml.
How do we explain the fact that the brown gas was able to be stored in the 500ml jar as in the first picture?The logical explanation is it can be compressed to occupy a smaller space.
Best wishes
Interestingly, we seem to be looking at the same thing from 2 different angles and I understand where u are coming from.
My understanding is when the brown gas is filled into the jar and covered w/ cardboard, the volume of the brown gas need not be compressed to fill up the jar. Only a small volume of brown gas is required and volume of gas filled in need not be greater than the volume of the jar. The brown gas will expand to fill up the volume of the whole jar. There is no issue of the brown gas being compressed into the jar in the first place.
My 2 point is the experiment is to itself. The 1st picture shows the initial condition of the experiment. The 2nd picture shows the final condition. I interpret the question as asking for the properties of the brown gas as result of the experiment . (Change that has taken place) -
in this case, the brown gas only became DILUTED when combined with the air. Similarly air did not disappear or compressed to zero volume. The TOTAL volume before and after the removal of the cardboard did not change.
-
Molly is a fish, no doubt abt it…
-
Full.Cream:
Hi I'm a P6 student and I think that if you cut the leaves, there will be less photosynthesis and so it will use less water.
for plants, i believe the answers will always revolve around water, air & sunlight. the answer is probably to reduce the (i) sunlight & (ii)CO2 which will slow down photosynthesis (sun + CO2 + water = starch). Not sure how this can be achieve, tho. :oops:MdmKS:
Got this problem from my P3 child worksheet.
A conical flask contain some water and a plant with its roots submerged in the water. A stopper is fixed at the mouth of the flask holding the stem of the plant with its leaves hanging outside the conical flask. Sorry, I am not sure how to upload the image file here.
Question : how to reduce the rate of water being absorbed by the roots? Give 2 methods, without changing the setting of the experiments.
T!A
Hope this helps!
From: PlasmStorm
(Formerly, kohjl Jr
)
-
PlasmaStorm:
Hi I'm a P6 student and I think that if you cut the leaves, there will be less photosynthesis and so it will use less water.
for plants, i believe the answers will always revolve around water, air & sunlight. the answer is probably to reduce the (i) sunlight & (ii)CO2 which will slow down photosynthesis (sun + CO2 + water = starch). Not sure how this can be achieve, tho. :oops:Full.Cream:
[quote=\"MdmKS\"]Got this problem from my P3 child worksheet.
A conical flask contain some water and a plant with its roots submerged in the water. A stopper is fixed at the mouth of the flask holding the stem of the plant with its leaves hanging outside the conical flask. Sorry, I am not sure how to upload the image file here.
Question : how to reduce the rate of water being absorbed by the roots? Give 2 methods, without changing the setting of the experiments.
T!A
Hope this helps!
From: PlasmStorm
(Formerly, kohjl Jr
)[/quote]
Since you have cut the leaves, I shall cut the stems / branches to remove some of the water carrying tubes. -
tianzhu:
Hi Dharma
SorryTianzhu, I missed this out earlier.Dharma:
[quote=\"tianzhu\"]Hi, Dharma and Full.Cream
There are some missing information in one of my previous post.Here is the revision.Please follow this link.
http://www.oldschool.com.sg/index.php/module/PublicAccess/action/Wrapper/sid/a1d5550a35132f7d768a9cd73d70318e/mcq_id/15658
I am sorry for the inconvenience.
When the cardboard is removed, the light brown gas will spread to fill up the whole of the jar and flask.
This tells us that
1.\tGas has no definite shape – it takes up the shape of the container that it is in.
2.\tGas has no fixed volume – it spreads to fill up the space in the flask in addition to the space it has already filled in the jar.
The answer is Option C – B & C
# Although air can be compressed but the experiment does not demonstrate this property of air.
I’ve been looking at this question for quite a number of times. It’s a pretty interesting one.
The first diagram shows the brown gas in a jar.
The second diagram shows the brown gas occupying the volume of the jar as well as the flask. It expands.
From the first diagram, the brown gas take up a smaller space in the jar .Therefore it can be compressed. After the cardboard is removed, it expands to take up the combined capacities of the jar and flask.
So this experiment shows that air has no definite shape, volume and is compressible. What’s your view on this?[/quote]Hi Tianzhu, in your second post, you say that the air expands to take up the VOLUME of the two jars but this does not show that air has a definite volume. That is true, but in oldschool.com, after seeing the diagram, it is seen that the air rises to take up the space inside the jar, not the volume, basically rise to fill up the SPACE inside, and not the volume. And the cardboard covering COMPRESSED the air, so when the flask was initially put on top of the jar, the gas did not rise up to fill the space in the jar...
So I think that the correct answer should be A and B. -
MdmKS:
Hi MdmKS, I think you could reduce the amount of water in the set-up, and chop off the roots. This changes the plant, but not the setting of the experiment. Settings of an experiment mean that the plant should not be moved to a different location...Got this problem from my P3 child worksheet.
A conical flask contain some water and a plant with its roots submerged in the water. A stopper is fixed at the mouth of the flask holding the stem of the plant with its leaves hanging outside the conical flask. Sorry, I am not sure how to upload the image file here.
Question : how to reduce the rate of water being absorbed by the roots? Give 2 methods, without changing the setting of the experiments.
T!A -
Here is a question found in a p3 science bk:
Question: What is the similarity between a robot and a baby?
My son's ans:Both have systems.
Teacher's ans: Both have hands and legs.
Which is a better ans? Pls help,thnx!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login1
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects