Is GEP really necessary?
-
Was wondering aloud, If the gep tests are a good selection tools, how can the ‘hothouse’ kids take up the place of those gifted one, yes iq questions can be trained but those gifted ones somehow will still manage the tests n ace them unless there is a quota in gep then it will be a different story altogether. So let give those parents that desperate to get their kids into the programme some due respect too. After all we should respect individual choice. There is no right and wrong n parents being parents all have the best intention for their kids …
-
:goodpost:
Suz855:
I am actually pro GEP( my kid in mainstream ), these kids love independent work n show great passion in the area they are interested in. They need facilitator n not teachers. However, high ability or hardworking kid like my girl, they still need to be taught the fundamental to help them see lights... Throwing them project n independent work (teach less learn more) simply stress us .

:goodpost: This will surface when they enter IP programme in sec school. -
toddles:
Donch like that part on interview.
how? like my suggestion or not?
We adults also donch like interview so why put these young kids thru it? Also, some of them may be 'thinkers' more than 'talkers', so u will also lose some truly gifted in this process. -
toddles:
Love your suggestion.
Like I mentioned earlier, having parents go into a GEP prep class frenzy is not a good enough reason to abolish the GEP.
If the problem is with fake-hot-housed \"GEP\" kids taking up spaces when they are just muggertoads instead of truly special needs gifted, then better selection processes might be it? Like I mentioned earlier, perhaps throw in an interview? Afterall, it's somewhat a scholarship with taxpayers money and all the other scholarships require face to face interviews.
Another suggestion to refine the selection / admission process. Instead of requiring more, require LESS. If we are prepared to be really drastic, and deal the tuition industry a significant overall blow, make GEP admission conditional on having the parents and the child sign a declaration that they have not undergone ANY FORM OF TUITION since P1. In the old days, most GEPers had zero tuition anyway.
Like smurf said, if you're gifted, you're gifted, should be in the least need of tuition.
Although I do acknowledge that tuition these days are geared towards coping within the crazy MOE testing system. So for those who are truly gifted whose parents are brave enough to eschew the whole system, just go the no-tuition route, and qualify when the time comes.
For those kiasu hot-house loving parents, they might also die die want a chance to be GEP elite mamas and papas, so they might risk not having any tuition to qualify.
And after the declaration if there is any evidence to show that they child had tuition, then like false declaration of address for P1 registration, there must be severe penalties.
how? like my suggestion or not?
2 birds with one stone - no prepped students in GEP and lower P students not forced into tution.
During the interview just ask the child. Most children cant lie under scrutiny. -
Nebbermind:
The interview should not be access intelligence, more pschycological.
Donch like that part on interview.toddles:
how? like my suggestion or not?
We adults also donch like interview so why put these young kids thru it? Also, some of them may be 'thinkers' more than 'talkers', so u will also lose some truly gifted in this process. -
Then parents will look for courses that will teach their kids to tell half truths and interview techniques to browbeat the interviewers. Additional business for enrichment centers. :rotflmao:
-
Suz855:
Was wondering aloud, If the gep tests are a good selection tools, how can the 'hothouse' kids take up the place of those gifted one, yes iq questions can be trained but those gifted ones somehow will still manage the tests n ace them unless there is a quota in gep then it will be a different story altogether. So let give those parents that desperate to get their kids into the programme some due respect too. After all we should respect individual choice. There is no right and wrong n parents being parents all have the best intention for their kids ...
urm, this is not abt whether we give those parents respect. it's abt how GEP is not abt \"qualifying\" through hot-housing, but just as a program to cater to those who are just naturally different.
it's not abt individual choice. it should not be. GEP is not a programme instituted to let parents CHOOSE to send their kids to special prep classes to \"train\" to be gifted. GEP is meant for children who are gifted without doing 10 year series of IQ tests. -
The purpose of interview is to know more about the pupil’s strengths and weakness and how the gep is going to bring out the best in him/her.
Such information can never be easily obtained from selection tests.
If a child is a thinker and not able to express his/her views to the audience, the child is just unsuited for the programme. -
Mawar:
Then parents will look for courses that will teach their kids to tell half truths and interview techniques to browbeat the interviewers. Additional business for enrichment centers. :rotflmao:
Quick patent ur business idea
-
toddles:
Suz855:
Was wondering aloud, If the gep tests are a good selection tools, how can the 'hothouse' kids take up the place of those gifted one, yes iq questions can be trained but those gifted ones somehow will still manage the tests n ace them unless there is a quota in gep then it will be a different story altogether. So let give those parents that desperate to get their kids into the programme some due respect too. After all we should respect individual choice. There is no right and wrong n parents being parents all have the best intention for their kids ...
urm, this is not abt whether we give those parents respect. it's abt how GEP is not abt \"qualifying\" through hot-housing, but just as a program to cater to those who are just naturally different.
it's not abt individual choice. it should not be. GEP is not a programme instituted to let parents CHOOSE to send their kids to special prep classes to \"train\" to be gifted. GEP is meant for children who are gifted without doing 10 year series of IQ tests.
I agreed with toddles' points.
If one will to analyse the performance of the very good 0-level performers that are admitted to top jcs, those who studied very hard just to keep up with the scores did not perform as well as those who know how to study intelligently. In fact these very hard working students are better off studying in other jcs.
Natural ability makes alot of difference in the final outcome.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login2
Online211.4k
Users34.6k
Topics1.8m
PostsMaths
English
Chinese
Multiple subjects